Pet food label hero image

How to Read Pet Food Labels: Ingredients to Avoid and What to Look For

Understanding how to read pet food labels is one of the most important steps you can take toward making informed nutritional choices for your dog or cat. Unfortunately, pet food packaging can be confusing, with marketing terms like “premium,” “natural,” and “holistic” that don’t always reflect the quality of the ingredients inside.

The ingredient list doesn’t always tell the whole story. Practices such as ingredient splitting, vague ingredient descriptions, and the use of highly processed ingredients can make it difficult to evaluate what’s really in your pet’s food.

In this guide, we’ll explain how to decode dog and cat food labels, identify ingredients worth questioning, understand common marketing claims, and recognize the differences between highly processed foods and fresh, minimally processed alternatives.

Our goal is to help pet parents look beyond attractive packaging and make informed choices that support their pets’ long-term health and nutritional needs.

Why Fewer Ingredients May Be Better

A long ingredient list does not automatically mean a food is more nutritious. In many cases, it means the product has been heavily processed and then rebuilt with flavorings, preservatives, starches, synthetic vitamins, minerals, and texture-enhancing ingredients.

A simple ingredient panel is often easier for the body to recognize and digest. It is also easier for pet parents to identify possible food intolerances.

A raw or gently cooked food may contain ingredients such as:

  • Turkey
  • Turkey heart
  • Turkey liver
  • Ground bone
  • Sardines
  • A small number of carefully selected vegetables
  • Whole-food supplements when needed for balance

Compare that with a kibble containing several protein meals, pea fractions, corn ingredients, artificial colors, flavor enhancers, preservatives, gums, fillers, and dozens of isolated vitamins and minerals.

In holistic feeding, simplicity matters. The goal is not merely to find a shorter label. The goal is to choose a food made from recognizable ingredients that provide real nutritional value.

Human-Grade vs. Feed-Grade Pet Food: What’s the Difference?

Human-grade and feed-grade pet foods may look similar on the shelf, but these terms describe important differences in ingredient standards, handling, processing, storage, and manufacturing.

Human-Grade Pet Food

For a pet food to legitimately carry a human-grade claim, every ingredient and the finished product must meet applicable human-food standards. The food must also be manufactured, packaged, stored, and transported according to human-food requirements.

Simply using human-grade chicken or beef does not make an entire pet food human-grade. The complete manufacturing process must qualify.

Feed-Grade Pet Food

Feed-grade ingredients are suitable for animal feed under applicable regulations but do not necessarily meet human-food requirements. Some ingredients may be perfectly acceptable for animal consumption, while others may be unsuitable for the human-food supply.

Feed-grade does not automatically mean contaminated, unsafe, or nutritionally inadequate. However, these foods may contain ingredients or undergo processing that would not qualify under human-food standards.

Depending on the formulation, some conventional feed-grade pet foods may contain:

  • Rendered meat or poultry meals

  • Vaguely identified animal ingredients

  • Unnamed animal fats

  • Added flavor coatings

  • Inexpensive starches and fillers

  • Synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes

These ingredients are not automatically harmful simply because they appear in a feed-grade food. Their quality, sourcing, digestibility, and role in the finished diet deserve closer examination.

Why This Matters for Your Pet’s Health

Dogs and cats often eat the same food every day for years. Choosing foods with transparent sourcing, clearly identified animal proteins, appropriate nutritional balance, and reliable manufacturing standards is an important part of a holistic nutrition approach.

However, human-grade does not automatically mean healthier or nutritionally superior. A human-grade recipe may still contain excessive starches, unnecessary additives, or an inappropriate balance of nutrients.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Whenever possible, consider a nutritionally complete and balanced raw or gently cooked food made with fresh, clearly identified ingredients, including appropriate animal proteins and organs. Look for transparent sourcing, minimal unnecessary additives, and careful quality-control practices.

Ultimately, the goal is not simply to choose a food labeled human-grade, but to select a safe, high-quality diet that meets your dog or cat’s individual nutritional needs.

Animal Digest: What Is It in Pet Food?

Animal digest is commonly added to kibble to make it smell and taste more appealing. It is produced by chemically or enzymatically breaking down animal tissues into a concentrated flavoring.

The problem is that the term “animal digest” is vague. The label may not clearly identify which animal was used, what tissues were included, or where the ingredients came from.

This is especially concerning for pets with allergies, food sensitivities, irritable bowel syndrome, chronic itching, or recurring ear infections. A pet parent may believe they are avoiding a particular protein while an unidentified animal flavoring is hidden in the food.

Pet Food Ingredients to Avoid

Animal Digest: What Is It in Pet Food?

Animal digest is a concentrated flavoring commonly added to dry pet food (kibble) to improve its smell and taste. It is produced by breaking down animal tissues through enzymatic or chemical hydrolysis, creating a highly palatable ingredient that can be sprayed onto kibble or incorporated into the food.

The biggest concern with animal digest is ingredient transparency. When a label simply lists “animal digest,” pet parents may not know which animal species were used, what tissues were included, or where the ingredients originated.

This can be particularly concerning for dogs and cats with food allergies and sensitivities, irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), chronic itching, or recurring ear infections. Pets undergoing an elimination diet may need to avoid unidentified animal proteins, even when they appear only as flavoring ingredients.

Animal digest is also used to increase the palatability of highly processed pet foods (kibble). While it is not automatically harmful, an appealing flavor coating does not necessarily indicate that the underlying food contains high-quality ingredients or provides optimal nutrition.

Our Holistic Recommendation: Choose pet foods that clearly identify their animal protein sources and prioritize transparent ingredient sourcing. For pets with suspected food allergies, avoid vaguely labeled animal-derived ingredients unless the manufacturer can confirm their exact sources.

Whole Meat Versus Meat Meal

Whole meat and meat meal are commonly found in dog and cat foods, but they differ significantly in moisture content and processing.

Whole Meat

Whole meat, such as fresh chicken, turkey, or beef, contains its natural moisture, typically around 65–75%. Because pet food ingredients are listed by weight before processing, fresh meat may appear first on an ingredient label partly because of its water content.

Whole meat provides animal protein and naturally occurring nutrients, but its position on the ingredient list doesn’t necessarily indicate how much animal protein remains in the finished food.

Meat Meal

Meat meal is produced through rendering, a process that uses heat to remove much of the moisture and fat from animal tissues. The remaining material is ground into a concentrated, protein-rich ingredient.

A clearly identified meal, such as chicken meal or turkey meal, is not automatically unsafe or nutritionally inadequate. However, it is a more heavily processed ingredient than fresh meat.

High-temperature processing can affect certain heat-sensitive nutrients and protein quality, depending on the processing conditions. Manufacturers may use added synthetic vitamins and minerals to ensure the finished food meets nutritional requirements.

Why Ingredient Transparency Matters

Vaguely labeled animal-derived ingredients make it more difficult to determine the exact protein sources in a pet food.

Watch for terms such as:

  • Meat meal

  • Animal meal

  • Poultry meal

  • Meat and bone meal

These terms can represent different ingredients and processing methods. Although they are not automatically unsafe, they may provide less information about the animal species used, which is particularly important for pets with food sensitivities.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Whenever possible, consider nutritionally balanced raw or gently cooked foods made with fresh, clearly identified animal proteins and organs.

These foods generally retain more natural moisture and may undergo less intensive processing than conventional kibble. However, freshness alone doesn’t guarantee nutritional completeness, so appropriate formulation and safe handling remain essential.

The bottom line: Look beyond whether the label lists whole meat or meat meal. Consider ingredient transparency, processing methods, nutritional balance, and the quality of the finished food.

Meat By-Products

The term “meat by-products” can be misleading because not all animal by-products are undesirable. In fact, many animal organs are nutrient-dense and can be valuable components of a balanced diet for dogs and cats.

Organs such as liver, heart, kidney, spleen, and pancreas provide naturally occurring vitamins, minerals, amino acids, and other important nutrients. In a properly formulated raw or gently cooked diet, clearly identified organ meats can contribute significantly to nutritional balance.

The concern isn’t necessarily the organ itself. It’s the lack of ingredient transparency.

For example, “beef liver” clearly identifies the animal species and organ, while “meat by-products” does not specify the exact tissues or animal species used.

Vaguely labeled by-products may vary in composition and make it more difficult for pet parents to identify potential allergens or evaluate ingredient quality. However, by-products are not automatically unsafe or nutritionally inferior.

Look for clearly identified animal ingredients such as:

  • Chicken heart

  • Turkey liver

  • Beef kidney

  • Pork spleen

Our Holistic Recommendation

Choose foods that clearly identify their animal protein sources and organ meats whenever possible. Fresh, appropriately sourced organs can be an excellent addition to a species-appropriate diet, provided the overall recipe is nutritionally complete and balanced.

The bottom line: Organ meats can provide exceptional nutritional value. Ingredient transparency, sourcing, processing, and proper nutritional balance matter far more than whether an ingredient is classified as a by-product.

Artificial Colors in Pet Food

Artificial colors are added to pet food primarily to make it more visually appealing to the people purchasing it, not to improve its nutritional value.

Dogs and cats do not need their food to be red, yellow, green, or brown. Artificial dyes are sometimes used in highly processed kibble and treats to create a more attractive or consistent appearance, but they provide no nutritional benefit to pets.

Common artificial food dyes include:

  • Red 40

  • Yellow 5

  • Yellow 6

  • Blue 1

  • Blue 2

Although approved artificial colors are regulated for use in animal foods, their presence does not make a food healthier. Some pets may have individual sensitivities to certain additives, although evidence linking approved food dyes to common chronic health problems in dogs and cats is limited.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Choose pet foods and treats made with recognizable, high-quality ingredients and without unnecessary artificial colors. Focus on nutritional quality, ingredient transparency, and minimal unnecessary processing rather than appearance.

The bottom line: Artificial colors serve a cosmetic purpose, not a nutritional one. Real, wholesome pet food doesn’t need artificial dyes to provide good nutrition.

Synthetic Vitamins and Minerals in Pet Food

Many commercial pet foods, particularly highly processed kibble, rely on added synthetic vitamins and minerals to replace nutrients lost during manufacturing and meet established nutritional requirements.

High-temperature processing can reduce certain naturally occurring nutrients. Manufacturers often compensate by adding isolated vitamins and minerals, including:

  • Thiamine mononitrate (vitamin B1)

  • Folic acid (vitamin B9)

  • Ferrous sulfate (iron)

  • Copper sulfate (copper)

  • Zinc oxide (zinc)

  • Sodium selenite (selenium)

  • Vitamin A acetate (vitamin A)

The concern is that excessive amounts of certain vitamins and minerals can be toxic, and mistakes in formulation or manufacturing can have devastating consequences.

The Hill’s Science Diet vitamin D recall demonstrated this danger. Excessive vitamin D in affected dog foods was associated with serious illness and deaths. This highlights why careful formulation, ingredient testing, and manufacturing oversight are essential.

Whole foods provide complex combinations of nutrients rather than isolated vitamins and minerals alone. For example:

  • Liver provides naturally occurring vitamin A, iron, copper, and B vitamins.

  • Sardines provide omega-3 fatty acids, protein, and other important nutrients.

  • Eggs provide highly digestible protein, fats, vitamins, and minerals.

However, naturally occurring nutrients can also become harmful in excessive amounts, and whole-food ingredients must be properly balanced.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Prioritize nutritionally complete and balanced raw or gently cooked diets made with fresh, clearly identified meats, organs, and other nutrient-dense whole foods.

Look for manufacturers that emphasize whole-food nutrition, transparent sourcing, appropriate nutrient testing, and minimal unnecessary additives.

When supplementation is necessary to achieve nutritional balance, both the amount and form of each nutrient deserve careful consideration.

Learn more in our detailed guide to Synthetic Vitamins in Pet Food.

The bottom line: Synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes deserve scrutiny. Excessive fortification, formulation errors, and inadequate quality control can put pets at serious risk. Nutrient balance and manufacturing safety should never be taken for granted.

Ingredient Splitting in Pet Food

Ingredient splitting is a pet food labeling practice that can make a product appear to contain more meat and fewer carbohydrates than it actually does.

Pet food ingredients are listed in descending order by weight before processing, including their natural moisture content. When a manufacturer uses several different forms of the same carbohydrate source, each appears separately on the ingredient list.

For example, a dog or cat food may list:

  • Chicken

  • Pea protein

  • Pea starch

  • Pea flour

  • Pea fiber

Chicken appears first, giving the impression that the food is primarily meat-based. However, if all the pea-derived ingredients were combined, their total weight could exceed that of the chicken.

This is especially important because fresh chicken contains substantial moisture, while many processed pea ingredients contain much less water.

Other ingredients that may be split include:

  • Corn, corn gluten meal, and corn flour

  • Rice, rice bran, and rice flour

  • Potatoes, potato starch, and potato protein

  • Lentils, lentil flour, and lentil fiber

  • Wheat, wheat flour, and wheat middlings

When reading pet food labels, look for multiple forms of the same plant ingredient and consider their combined contribution to the recipe. Although the exact percentages cannot usually be determined from the ingredient list alone, repeated plant fractions can indicate that carbohydrates or plant-derived proteins make up a substantial portion of the food.

Plant protein concentrates can also contribute to the crude protein percentage listed in the guaranteed analysis, even though they do not provide the same amino acid profile as animal proteins.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Choose nutritionally balanced, species-appropriate pet foods that prioritize clearly identified animal proteins and organs rather than relying heavily on multiple plant-derived ingredients.

The bottom line: Don’t assume that a food is meat-rich simply because chicken, beef, or another animal protein appears first. Look at the entire ingredient list, including repeated forms of grains, legumes, and starches.

The Salt Line: A Trick for Reading Pet Food Labels

The salt line is a useful trick for evaluating pet food ingredient labels and identifying ingredients that may be included in very small amounts.

Salt is generally added to commercial pet foods in relatively small quantities. Because ingredients are listed in descending order by weight before processing, ingredients appearing after salt are often present in similarly small or smaller amounts.

For example, a pet food may prominently advertise ingredients such as:

  • Blueberries

  • Cranberries

  • Spinach

  • Turmeric

  • Kale

  • Pumpkin

These ingredients may sound nutritious, but if they appear near the bottom of the ingredient list, particularly after salt, they may contribute relatively little to the overall nutritional profile.

This is where pet food marketing can be misleading. A package may feature colorful fruits, vegetables, and superfoods even though those ingredients make up only a tiny portion of the recipe.

However, the salt line is not an exact measurement. Some nutrients and functional ingredients can provide benefits in small amounts, and the amount of salt varies between recipes.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Pay particular attention to the ingredients listed before salt, as they generally represent larger individual contributions to the formula. Look for clearly identified animal proteins, nutritious organs, and other high-quality ingredients rather than relying on marketing images or claims.

The bottom line: Don’t judge a pet food by the attractive ingredients pictured on the bag. Read the entire ingredient list and consider where those ingredients actually appear.

Artificial Preservatives in Pet Food

Pet foods containing fats and oils require proper preservation to prevent oxidation and rancidity.Many highly processed pet foods, including kibble, are designed to remain shelf-stable for months

Common synthetic preservatives to watch for include:

  • BHA (Butylated Hydroxyanisole)

  • BHT (Butylated Hydroxytoluene)

  • Ethoxyquin

  • Propyl Gallate

These preservatives help slow fat oxidation, but some have raised questions about their long-term safety. Their regulatory status and permitted uses differ, and the presence of a preservative does not automatically mean a food is unsafe.

From a holistic nutrition perspective, freshness and ingredient quality should take priority over unnecessary chemical additives.

Raw and gently cooked pet foods generally require refrigeration or freezing to maintain freshness and food safety. Their shorter refrigerated shelf life reflects different processing and storage methods, although it does not automatically make them more nutritious or safer than shelf-stable foods.

For dry, air-dried, or freeze-dried pet foods, look for manufacturers that use alternative preservation methods, such as:

  • Mixed tocopherols (forms of vitamin E)

  • Rosemary extract

  • Appropriate packaging that limits oxygen exposure

  • Clearly stated storage instructions and expiration dates

Natural preservatives can help slow oxidation, but they do not eliminate the need for proper storage or prevent every type of spoilage.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Whenever possible, choose fresh, minimally processed pet foods made with clearly identified ingredients and transparent manufacturing practices. If feeding shelf-stable foods, look for appropriate preservation methods, quality testing, and clear information about ingredient sourcing.

The bottom line: Preserving food is necessary for safety, but pet parents should understand which preservatives are used and why. Prioritize freshness, ingredient transparency, and nutritional quality rather than choosing food solely for its long shelf life.

Added Sugars and Sweeteners in Pet Food

Dogs and cats have no nutritional requirement for added sugars or sweeteners in their daily diets. Yet some commercial pet foods and treats contain added sugars to enhance flavor, improve texture, promote browning, or make highly processed ingredients more appealing.

When reading pet food labels, watch for ingredients such as:

  • Corn syrup

  • Cane molasses

  • Sugar

  • Caramel

  • Dextrose

  • Fructose

These ingredients provide little nutritional value beyond calories and are generally unnecessary in a balanced diet.

Regular consumption of foods containing excessive added sugars can contribute to unwanted calorie intake and weight gain. Depending on the overall diet and individual pet, high-sugar foods may also complicate blood-glucose management, particularly in pets with diabetes.

Important Safety Warning: Xylitol, also called birch sugar, is extremely toxic to dogs and can cause a rapid, potentially life-threatening drop in blood sugar and serious liver injury. It should never be included in food or treats given to dogs.

Cats are obligate carnivores and have no dietary requirement for added sugars. Dogs can digest carbohydrates, but they do not need added sweeteners to obtain complete and balanced nutrition.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Choose dog and cat foods made with clearly identified animal proteins, nutritious organs, and other appropriate whole-food ingredients rather than products relying on added sugars to improve palatability.

The bottom line: Added sugars are unnecessary in a nutritionally balanced pet food. Read ingredient labels carefully, especially on treats, soft chews, and highly processed products.

Unnamed Animal Fats

Animal fats provide energy, essential fatty acids, and flavor in pet food. However, not all animal fats are equal, and ingredient transparency matters.

When reading dog and cat food labels, watch for vague ingredients such as:

  • Animal fat

  • Animal fat preserved with mixed tocopherols

  • Poultry fat

  • Rendered animal fat

These terms may not clearly identify the animal species used. For example, “chicken fat” tells you the source, while “animal fat” does not.

Why Unnamed Animal Fats Are Concerning

Animal fats may come from rendered animal tissues, and their quality depends on the original ingredients, processing methods, storage conditions, and preservation practices.

Unnamed fats can raise several concerns:

  • Unknown Animal Sources: It may be difficult to determine which animal species contributed to the fat.

  • Food Sensitivities: Pets with confirmed food allergies may require careful evaluation of all animal-derived ingredients. Highly purified fats generally contain little protein, but residual proteins can sometimes be present.

  • Oxidation and Rancidity: Improperly processed or stored fats can oxidize, affecting flavor and nutritional quality.

  • Limited Transparency: Vague labeling makes it harder for pet parents to evaluate sourcing and manufacturing standards.

Fats are also commonly sprayed onto kibble to improve palatability. While this is not inherently harmful, an appealing fat coating does not guarantee that the underlying food contains high-quality ingredients.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Choose pet foods that clearly identify their fat sources, such as chicken fat, beef fat, or salmon oil. Look for transparent sourcing, appropriate preservation methods, and quality-control testing.

Whenever possible, prioritize nutritionally complete and balanced raw or gently cooked diets containing appropriate amounts of naturally occurring animal fats.

The bottom line: Animal fats are an important part of canine and feline nutrition, but pet parents deserve to know where those fats come from. Clearly identified sources, freshness, and proper handling are essential considerations when evaluating pet food quality.

Excessive Starches, Grains, and Legumes

Corn, wheat, rice, peas, lentils, chickpeas, potatoes, and tapioca are not automatically harmful to dogs and cats. The concern is how much of the diet they make up and whether they displace high-quality animal proteins and fats.

Most conventional kibble requires starch for extrusion and to maintain its shape. Even many grain-free pet foods rely heavily on peas, lentils, chickpeas, potatoes, or tapioca as alternatives to grains.

Why Excessive Starches and Plant Proteins Matter

  • Carbohydrate Content: Some dry pet foods contain substantial amounts of starch, which may reduce the proportion of animal-derived ingredients in the recipe.

  • Plant Protein Concentrates: Ingredients such as pea protein, potato protein, and corn gluten meal contribute to the crude protein percentage on the guaranteed analysis. However, crude protein alone does not reveal protein quality, digestibility, or amino acid balance.

  • Ingredient Splitting: Multiple forms of the same grain or legume may appear separately on the ingredient list, making their combined contribution less obvious.

  • Individual Nutritional Needs: Cats are obligate carnivores and require specific nutrients from animal-derived sources. Dogs are more metabolically flexible and can utilize properly prepared carbohydrates, but they still require adequate high-quality protein and essential fats.

What About Grain-Free Pet Foods?

Grain-free does not automatically mean healthier or lower in carbohydrates. Some grain-free formulas simply replace grains with large amounts of legumes or potatoes.

Certain diets containing high proportions of pulses, including peas and lentils, have also been investigated for a possible association with diet-associated dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs. The precise mechanisms and causal relationships remain unresolved, so grain-free status alone cannot establish whether a food is safe or unsafe.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Prioritize nutritionally complete and balanced, species-appropriate foods featuring clearly identified animal proteins, nutritious organs, and appropriate fats.

Carefully selected vegetables, fruits, seeds, and herbs can contribute fiber and beneficial plant compounds, but they should complement rather than unnecessarily displace essential animal-derived nutrition.

The bottom line: Don’t assume a pet food is healthier because it’s grain-free or advertises a high crude-protein percentage. Evaluate the entire ingredient list, the sources of protein, carbohydrate content, processing methods, and overall nutritional balance.

Natural Flavor

The term “natural flavor” may sound reassuring, but it doesn’t necessarily tell pet parents exactly what ingredients are being used or where they originated.

Natural flavors are commonly added to processed pet foods (kibble)  to enhance aroma and palatability. They may be derived from animal or plant sources, and the ingredient label may not identify the specific source.

Why Natural Flavors Can Be Concerning

  • Unidentified Proteins: Animal-derived flavorings may contain proteins from sources that aren’t clearly disclosed.

  • Food Allergies and Sensitivities: Pets with confirmed food allergies or those undergoing an elimination diet may need to avoid flavorings with unidentified animal sources.

  • Limited Transparency: The term “natural” describes the origin of the flavoring, not necessarily its nutritional value or suitability for every pet.

This is especially important for dogs and cats experiencing chronic itching, recurring ear infections, digestive upset, or suspected food intolerances.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Choose pet foods made with clearly identified animal proteins and transparent ingredient sourcing. If a manufacturer cannot explain what its natural flavor contains, consider a food with more clearly identified ingredients.

The bottom line: Natural flavor doesn’t automatically mean harmful, but it doesn’t guarantee ingredient quality or transparency either. Pet parents deserve to know what they’re feeding their dogs and cats.

Carrageenan, Gums, and Thickeners

Canned, pouch, and other wet pet foods may contain carrageenan, guar gum, xanthan gum, cassia gum, or other ingredients used to thicken food, improve texture, and prevent ingredients from separating.

These additives primarily serve a manufacturing or texture-related purpose rather than providing essential nutrients. Some gums can also contribute soluble fiber.

Common thickeners found in pet food include:

  • Carrageenan

  • Guar gum

  • Xanthan gum

  • Cassia gum

  • Locust bean gum

Why Some Pet Parents Choose to Avoid Them

Although many pets tolerate these ingredients, certain gums and thickeners may contribute to gas, changes in stool consistency, or digestive discomfort in susceptible animals.

For pets with loose stools, nausea, or recurring digestive upset, it may be helpful to evaluate whether specific ingredients are contributing to their symptoms.

Dogs and cats with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) or other chronic gastrointestinal conditions may benefit from a carefully selected diet that minimizes ingredients they do not tolerate.

Carrageenan deserves particular attention because some research has raised concerns about inflammatory effects of degraded carrageenan. However, degraded carrageenan is different from food-grade carrageenan, and evidence that approved food-grade carrageenan causes intestinal inflammation in dogs and cats remains limited.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Whenever possible, choose nutritionally complete and balanced foods made with fresh, clearly identified ingredients and minimal unnecessary additives.

If your pet has a sensitive digestive system, consider a simpler formulation and monitor their individual response. Dietary changes should be evaluated carefully rather than assuming every gum or thickener is harmful.

For additional information about intestinal health, visit our Leaky Gut in Dogs and Cats resource.

The bottom line: Gums and thickeners aren’t essential nutrients, and some pets may tolerate foods without them better. Ingredient simplicity, individual tolerance, and nutritional balance should guide your choices.

 

Cellulose and Other Cheap Fillers

Cellulose is a form of insoluble plant fiber commonly added to commercial pet foods to increase bulk, reduce calorie density, and influence stool consistency. It may be derived from various plant materials, including wood pulp and other purified plant fibers.

Although fiber can play a beneficial role in digestive health, large amounts of low-nutrient fillers may displace more valuable animal-based ingredients in a pet’s diet.

Common inexpensive fiber ingredients to watch for include:

  • Powdered cellulose

  • Oat hulls

  • Peanut hulls

  • Soybean mill run

  • Wheat middlings

These ingredients are not automatically harmful, and some can provide useful dietary fiber. However, their nutritional contribution varies, and they should not replace adequate high-quality protein, essential fats, vitamins, and minerals.

Why Excessive Fillers May Be Concerning

  • Lower Nutrient Density: High concentrations of poorly digestible fiber can dilute the energy and nutrient density of a food.

  • Larger Stool Volume: Foods containing substantial amounts of insoluble fiber may produce larger stools because more undigested material passes through the digestive tract.

  • Digestive Tolerance: Some pets may experience increased gas, changes in stool consistency, or digestive discomfort when consuming excessive amounts of certain fibers.

  • Ingredient Quality: Large quantities of inexpensive plant-derived ingredients may indicate a formulation that prioritizes cost or calorie reduction rather than animal-based nutrition, although the complete recipe must be evaluated.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Choose nutritionally balanced, species-appropriate pet foods that prioritize clearly identified animal proteins, nutritious organs, and healthy fats, with appropriate amounts of beneficial fiber.

Fresh, minimally processed foods may offer greater nutrient density and digestibility, depending on their formulation and preparation.

The bottom line: Fiber has a place in canine and feline nutrition, but more isn’t always better. Focus on ingredient quality, nutrient density, digestibility, and your pet’s individual needs rather than choosing foods loaded with inexpensive fillers.

Rendered Fat and Flavor Coatings

Many commercial kibble products are coated with animal fats, animal digest, or concentrated flavor enhancers after cooking to improve their aroma and palatability.

These coatings can make highly processed foods especially appealing to dogs and cats, even when the underlying ingredients are less desirable from a holistic nutrition perspective.

Why Flavor Coatings Matter

Pets that have eaten the same highly flavored kibble for years may become accustomed to its smell, taste, and texture. As a result, some may initially resist fresh, minimally processed foods.

This doesn’t necessarily mean they dislike real food. They may simply need time to become familiar with different aromas and textures.

However, food preferences can also be influenced by individual taste, previous experiences, and medical conditions. A pet refusing food should not automatically be considered picky.

Transitioning to Fresh Food

When changing from kibble to a nutritionally balanced raw or gently cooked diet, a gradual transition may help some pets tolerate the dietary change and become accustomed to new flavors and textures.

Introduce new foods carefully, monitor stool consistency and appetite, and adjust the transition based on your pet’s individual response.

The bottom line: Flavor coatings can make kibble highly appealing, but palatability alone doesn’t determine nutritional quality. Focus on transparent ingredients, appropriate nutritional balance, and a feeding approach that supports your pet’s individual needs.

Why Raw and Gently Cooked Foods Are Different

Raw and gently cooked diets are generally made with fresh, clearly identified ingredients such as muscle meat, organs, appropriate animal fats, and other nutrient-dense whole foods.

Unlike conventional kibble, these foods typically retain their natural moisture and undergo less intensive processing. This can make them appealing to pet parents seeking a more species-appropriate, minimally processed approach to nutrition.

Potential Benefits of a Properly Balanced Fresh-Food Diet

Depending on the ingredients, formulation, and individual pet, potential benefits may include:

  • Better Hydration: Fresh foods naturally contain more moisture than dry kibble, contributing to daily water intake.

  • Smaller, Well-Formed Stools: Highly digestible diets with less indigestible material may produce smaller stools.

  • Improved Digestive Comfort: Some pets tolerate fresh, appropriately formulated foods better than certain highly processed diets.

  • Healthy Skin and Coat: Quality animal proteins and essential fatty acids support normal skin and coat health.

  • Steady Energy: Appropriate calories and balanced nutrients help support normal activity and energy levels.

  • Healthy Weight Management: Portion control and appropriate calorie density can help maintain an ideal body condition.

  • Improved Appetite: Many dogs and cats enjoy the aroma, texture, and taste of fresh foods.

  • Fewer Unnecessary Carbohydrates: Meat-focused fresh-food recipes may contain less starch than conventional kibble.

  • Greater Ingredient Transparency: Clearly identified meats, organs, and other whole-food ingredients make it easier to understand what your pet is eating.

Proper Nutritional Balance Is Essential

Raw feeding is not simply feeding raw meat. A complete and balanced diet must provide appropriate amounts of muscle meat, organs, calcium, phosphorus, essential fatty acids, vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients required for your pet’s species and life stage.

Gently cooked food can also be an excellent option for families who prefer not to feed raw, pets that tolerate cooked food better, or animals with specific dietary needs.

Raw diets require careful sourcing, preparation, and handling because uncooked animal ingredients can carry harmful pathogens. Gently cooking food can reduce these risks when appropriate food-safety practices are followed.

Our Holistic Recommendation

Choose a nutritionally complete and balanced, minimally processed diet made with fresh, clearly identified ingredients whenever practical. Consider your pet’s individual health, digestive tolerance, nutritional requirements, and your family’s ability to feed the diet consistently.

The bottom line: The goal isn’t simply to feed raw or gently cooked food. It’s to provide fresh, high-quality, species-appropriate nutrition that supports your pet’s long-term health while maintaining proper nutritional balance and food safety.

What to Look for in a Healthier Pet Food

When choosing food for your dog or cat, look beyond the marketing claims on the packaging. Ingredient quality, transparency, processing methods, and nutritional balance matter far more than attractive labels or advertising.

Choose pet foods with:

  • Clearly identified animal proteins

  • Named, nutrient-rich organ meats

  • Clearly identified animal fats and essential fatty acids

  • Human-grade ingredients whenever possible

  • A short, understandable ingredient list

  • Minimal unnecessary starches and legumes

  • No artificial colors or added sugars

  • No vaguely identified animal digest or flavorings

  • Minimal unnecessary gums, thickeners, and fillers

  • Whole-food sources of vitamins and minerals whenever possible

  • Transparent ingredient sourcing and manufacturing practices

  • Complete and balanced nutrition appropriate for your pet’s species and life stage

The first ingredients should look like real food.

Chicken, turkey, beef, rabbit, sardines, liver, heart, eggs, pumpkin, zucchini, and blueberries are examples of recognizable ingredients.

Vague terms such as animal digest, meat by-products, natural flavor, poultry meal, and unnamed animal fat deserve closer examination. Long lists of isolated vitamins and minerals also warrant questions about ingredient quality, processing, and the manufacturer’s nutritional philosophy.

The Bottom Line: Choose Real Food Over Marketing

Your pet may eat the same food every day for years. That’s why the quality of the ingredients, their nutritional value, and how they’re processed deserve careful attention.

From a holistic nutrition perspective, dogs and cats benefit from diets that prioritize appropriate animal proteins, nutritious organs, essential fats, and thoughtfully selected whole-food ingredients.

Rather than relying heavily on artificial colors, flavor coatings, unnecessary fillers, excessive starches, and extensive synthetic nutrient premixes, look for foods that deliver nutrition through high-quality ingredients.

Choose the least processed, nutritionally balanced food you can reasonably afford and manage. For many families, this may mean a properly formulated raw or gently cooked diet made with fresh meat, organs, healthy fats, and appropriate whole-food ingredients.

Human-grade ingredients are preferable when available, but the entire recipe still matters. A human-grade food can contain excessive starches or unnecessary additives, while a carefully formulated diet must also meet your pet’s nutritional requirements.

Don’t be fooled by the picture on the bag. Read the ingredient panel, look above the salt line, identify ingredient splitting, and question vague terminology.

The goal is to understand exactly what you’re placing in your pet’s bowl.

Continue Learning About Pet Food

For more information, explore our educational resources:

 

Food is medicine. Feed the body with real food, not marketing.

 

2 Responses

  1. I have followed this site since my sheltie was 15 weeks old…was diagnosed with a sarcoma and we had it removed knocked on wood it’s not back but could🙏🐾♥️…we give dr. Harvey’s freeze dried food and I faithfully make pup loaf …all natural treats…he’s 5 now and am still eternally grateful gor all the information from this site…THANKYOU! From Jill and Bentley

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Theme image of a jar of coins with a heart growing out of it.

Have we helped?

We’ve poured our hearts into creating this website for you, and we’re still bustling with excitement to keep it going! As a team of volunteers, we’re using our own resources to bring this information to life. There are many ways you can show your support for our efforts. We greatly appreciate it! If we’ve been able to help you on your journey to a healthier pet, we would love it if you consider showing your support.