Most dog food and pet food reviews focus on marketing claims, not what’s actually in the bowl. At first glance, many foods may look similar, but when you take a closer look at ingredients, sourcing, and how they’re processed, the differences can be significant. In this guide, we break down pet food options—including raw, gently cooked, air-dried, freeze-dried, and kibble—based on what truly supports long-term health, so you can make informed decisions for your dog or cat.
Check the pet food manufacturers website and see if they provide a complete pet food nutritional analysis on the site. If they don’t provide it, call or email them and request it. If they don’t provide it for proprietary reasons or any other reason this is a red flag. What are they hiding?
When shopping online, if you have to subscribe or enter your email to be able to see the ingredient labels this is another red flag. The company lacks transparency.
Just because you have fed a pet food for years doesn’t mean it’s good. Pet food manufacturers do not legally need to notify you when they are sold to another company or when they change their ingredients or packaging. You the pet parent have to be vigilant.
Follow the pet food manufacturer on their websites and social media. If they get sold you should be concerned. The acquiring company will often degrade the ingredients… profit over quality.
Choosing a healthy, nutritious pet food can feel overwhelming, especially with so many marketing claims competing for attention. Our goal is to make the process easier by looking beyond the front of the bag and examining ingredients, sourcing, processing, transparency, nutritional information, and recall history. We’ve reviewed a wide range of dog and cat foods and created recommendations based on foods we would feel comfortable feeding our own pets. Our reviews include options available in the USA, Canada, the UK, and Australia.
We’re often told that some of the foods we recommend are expensive. Higher-quality ingredients and less-processed foods can cost more, but nutrition is also an important part of long-term health. We won’t recommend a food simply because it is inexpensive if it doesn’t meet our standards. For pet parents working within a budget, we also share ways to improve the nutritional quality of the bowl with fresh whole-food additions and healthier toppers.
We base our pet food reviews and recommendations on the following holistic criteria (see our for short video):
Reviewing pet food is one of the most requested things our administrators do. When it comes to pet food reviews, we’re the critics your furry friends never knew they needed. No, we don’t own any brands — just a talent for sniffing out the truth! Arm yourself with the knowledge to keep your beloved companions munching happily and healthily for a very long time.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: AllProvide is top-quality pet food. Pet food manufacturer is very reputable and does their due diligence to ensure they provide excellent food.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: American Journey is cleverly marketed and very cost effective. Unfortunately it offers little nutrition and can cause a multitude of health issues. Feed a raw, gently cook, freeze-dried, or air-baked food instead.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Better than kibble but not as nutritious as a raw or gently cooked diet.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Not nutritious. We recommend as a raw or gently cooked diet.
We do not recommend BJ’s Raw. For legal reasons, we are unable to disclose the details, but we cannot in good conscience endorse this product.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Blue Buffalo is cleverly marketed but offers very little nutrition. We recommend you feed air baked, freeze-dried, gently cooked, or raw instead.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: CARNA4 is ideal for pet parents who are feeding kibble and want to improve their pet’s nutrition or need something with minimal fuss.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: One of the worse foods on the market. A raw or gently cooked diet is recommended.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Dr. Judy Morgan and Saving Pets recommends Dr. Harvey’s Raw Vibrance and Paradigm only.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
Note: All good pet food manufacturers publish ingredients on their website OR when you contact them, they will send you the information. Dr. Marty’s will not provide a complete nutritional breakdown if you ask for it. They say it’s proprietary. They lack transparency.
VERDICT: Dr. Marty’s is better than kibble. With higher carbohydrate content, no full nutrient panel and unclear safety protocols; we cannot recommend it.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Eukanuba is cleverly marketed, but it falls short in delivering substantial nutritional value and may contribute to various health issues. We recommend choosing raw, gently cooked, freeze-dried or air-baked food instead.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Evermore is top-quality pet food. They are transparent about their sourcing, processes, and ingredients. We highly recommend Evermore.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
You can get 15% off the first order using coupon code: SAVINGPETS.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Average food with clever marketing. Excessive synthetic vitamins makes it a no-go! A raw or gently cooked diet is recommended.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Farmina is better than a feed-grade kibble. However, due to their lack of transparency and the number of pets we have seen sick who eat this food we cannot recommend it.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: This is a hard NO. If you feed this food, please freshen up 20% of the bowl with protein, veggies and fruit.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Fresh Pet seems like a convenient upgrade from kibble but it falls short of being a healthy food.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Clever marketing; high risk pet food. A raw or gently cooked diet is recommended.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Gentle Giants is cleverly marketed but offers very little nutrition. It is high in carb and cheap fillers. We recommend you feed air baked, freeze-dried, gently cooked, or raw food instead.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Goodness Gracious is ideal for pet parents who want a low carb, high quality food.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
Note: Only Halo freeze-dried is decent to feed.
VERDICT: Not nutritious. We recommend a raw or gently cooked diet.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Hills is cleverly marketed and endorsed by veterinarians-some of whom receive nutrition education directly from Hills’s programs and sponsorship faculty positions. If your goal is optimal pet health, we recomend feeding a raw or genlty cooked diet instead.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Clever marketing. Better than kibble. Pet parents can do better feeding a raw or gently cooked diet.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: One of the worst foods on the market. A raw or gently cooked diet is recommended.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Instinct’s raw and freeze dried is better than any other kibble on the market.However, there are much better raw and freeze than Instinct. We do not recommend Instinct’s kibble.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Nature’s Logic Distinction (only) is a commendable choice for kibble feeders. However, we have significant concerns regarding Midwestern Pet Food’ acquisition of the company, as it raises questions about the brands future integrity.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Among the worst foods on the market. A raw or gently cooked diet is recommended.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Oma’s Pride is a good quality food and great for pets with sensitivities and allergies. This is a great option to consider!
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Orijen is one of the best quality kibble on the market. However, it still lacks moisture and enzymatic activity of fresh food that dogs and cats need. A raw or gently cooked diet is healthier.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Better than kibble but for the price you would be much better off feeding Raised Right, All Provide, Solutions Pet Food, Evermore, Goodness Gracious, Steve’s or Small Batch.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: One of the worst foods on the market. A raw or gently cooked diet is recommended.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: One of the worst foods on the market. A raw or gently cooked diet is recommended.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Raised Right is one of the cleanest pet foods you can buy with top-quality ingredients. If you want to keep your pet healthy buy Raised Right.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
You can get 20% off the first 16 bags of Raised Right Pet Food using coupon code: PETS 20.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Royal Canin is a skillfully marketed and freequently endorsed by vets- many of whom recieve education and training supported by MARS (its parent company). For optimum pet health, consider feeding a raw or gently cooked diet instead.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Small Batch is one of the cleanest pet foods in the industry. They offer top notch ingredients and minimal synthetic vitamins in the gently cooked only. Highly recommend.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Solutions Pet Food stands among the very best choices available. They have uncompromising standard-featuring ethically sourced , minimally processed ingredients. This sets them apart from others.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
You can get 10% off using coupon code: SAVINGPETS.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Stella & Chewy’s raw and freeze-dried products are more convenent and certainly better than most kibble – we still don’t feel comfortable recommending.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Steve’s is a premium food produced by a conscientious and reputable company. We highly recommend it.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
You can get 5% off with code for first time customers AND 10% off every subscription. Code: SAVINGPETS.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: It’s a mid-tier dog food brand with notable concerns. While it offers high-protein, grain-free formulas, issues such as past recalls, legal disputes, and potential links to heart conditions warrant caution. For optimal health, a raw or gently cooked diet is recommended.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: The Simple Food Project is a great freeze-dried option and a huge step up for kibble feeders. It’s great for anyone who wants a healthy, convenient and easy to feed food.
KELLY’S REVIEW: CLICK FOR A DETAILED ANALYSIS
You can get 10% off using code: SAVINGPETS.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Tuckers offers a nutritious alternative to kibble but raises concerns regarding quality control and transparency. We recommend considering brands like Simple Food Project, Small Batch, Steve’s, and Green Juju for more consistent and transparent options.
PROS:
CONS:
VERDICT: Vital Essentials is better than any kibble. We have concerns about their lack of quality control procedures and limited information regarding their nutrition. We recommend you consider Simple food Project, Small Batch, Steve’s, and Green Juju instead.
Viva Raw has been in business since late 2020. They have had three recalls in the last two years. They did not handle the recall in July 2024 well and were not transparent. They initially came out and said that none of their food that was impacted was released on the market, and then two days later, they issued a recall, and many pets were sick. It is better than any ultra-processed food but we have concerns about the company’s transparency and integrity.
We cannot recommend it. There are so many other great raw and gently cooked options (AllProvide, Raised Right, Solutions Pet Food, Evermore, Goodness Gracious and Small Batch). Why would you risk your pet’s life?
Another Facebook post to check out: “The 6 big pet food companies promoting low-quality diets.”
Kibble is typically ultra-processed and made using high heat, which can reduce nutrient integrity and require the addition of synthetic vitamins. Raw and gently cooked diets are less processed and often rely more heavily on whole-food ingredients. The best choice depends on your pet’s health, digestive tolerance and your comfort level with handling and storage.
Human-grade pet food must meet standards that allow the ingredients and final product to be legally edible for humans. Feed-grade food may include rendered ingredients or by-products not held to the same standards. However, labeling alone does not guarantee quality — sourcing, transparency and processing methods matter just as much. See our pet food ingredients page for more details.
Many commercial foods rely on synthetic vitamin premixes to replace nutrients lost during processing. While not inherently harmful, heavy reliance on synthetic fortification can indicate significant nutrient loss during manufacturing. Minimally processed diets often retain more naturally occurring nutrients. The owner of this page dog died from synthetic vitamins along with thousands of of other pets. You can read her story.
We encourage you to download and share these graphics for personal use and on social media, if desired. However, please note that these graphics cannot be altered in any manner, and you are not authorized to present them as your original creations.
The graphics presented herein are the intellectual property of the identified original creators, used with permission here, or are the result of our own development. Any use for resale or commercial purposes requires explicit written consent from the content creators.
If you’re committed to feeding your pet whole, species-appropriate food without the junk, AllProvide deserves your attention. This Georgia-based company is making waves in the raw and gently cooked pet food world — and for good reason. With USDA-inspected, human-grade meats and small-batch production in their own facility, AllProvide sets a high standard for quality and safety.
Real Ingredients, Minimal Carbs
AllProvide focuses on what pets truly need — high-quality animal protein, organ meats, and low-glycemic vegetables. Their meals are free from feed-grade ingredients, grains, legumes, and artificial additives. Better yet, their formulas are very low in carbohydrates, typically under 3% on a dry matter basis, making them ideal for pets with allergies, cancer, diabetes, or chronic inflammation.
Synthetic Vitamins?
AllProvide has no synthetic vitamins. Pets will get their vitamins naturally IN the food, not added in.
Full Nutritional Transparency
Unlike many brands that leave pet parents guessing, AllProvide provides a complete nutritional analysis, not just crude protein and fat. You can access full nutrient profiles — including vitamins, minerals, and fatty acids — which is essential if your pet is on a therapeutic or restricted diet. This level of transparency is rare and highly appreciated by holistic pet owners and veterinarians alike.
Safety First: No HPP, No Recalls
AllProvide does not use High Pressure Pasteurization (HPP), opting instead for flash-freezing to maintain raw food safety without compromising nutritional value. Their cooked recipes are gently prepared at low temperatures. Best of all, the company has never had a recall, showing a consistent track record of food safety and quality control.
Trusted by Pet Parents and Pros
With their focus on human-grade ingredients, transparent sourcing, low carbs, and no synthetics, AllProvide earns its spot among the most trustworthy pet food brands on the market. Whether you’re feeding raw or gently cooked, you can feel confident knowing your pet is getting real, nourishing food made with care. Order your AllProvide now!
If you’ve browsed Chewy.com, chances are you’ve come across American Journey — Chewy’s in-house brand for both dogs and cats. With eye-catching prices and claims of real meat and wholesome ingredients, it’s easy to see why many pet parents consider it. But how does it actually measure up when it comes to your pet’s long-term health?
Let’s take a closer look!
What’s in the Bag?
American Journey offers a wide selection of dry kibble, wet food, and limited-ingredient diets. Their formulas typically start with meat meals like chicken or salmon meal — these are more concentrated sources of protein than fresh meat but are also more processed. You’ll also find ingredients like sweet potatoes, peas, blueberries, and chickpeas. While fruits and veggies sound great, these formulas lean heavily on starches to bulk up the food, which means a higher carbohydrate content.
Carbohydrate Content
On average, American Journey’s dry foods contain 35–45% carbohydrates. That’s quite high for dogs and especially high for cats, who are obligate carnivores and thrive on protein and fat rather than starch. If you’re looking to reduce inflammation, support digestive health, or help manage allergies, excess carbs can work against you.
Do They Use Synthetic Vitamins?
Yes, like most kibble brands, American Journey relies on a full panel of synthetic vitamins and minerals to meet nutritional guidelines. While these help meet AAFCO standards, synthetic nutrients are not always as bioavailable or effective as those that come from whole foods.
Sourcing and Transparency
Here’s where things get murky. American Journey states their food is made in the USA, but doesn’t disclose exactly where or from what sources their ingredients come. They also don’t publicly share any third-party testing or food safety protocols. For pet parents who care deeply about ingredient quality and transparency, that’s an area to be cautious about.
Recalls
As of now, American Journey has not had any recalls. That’s great news — but it’s also worth noting that as a private label brand, their manufacturing and safety processes aren’t as public as some independent pet food companies.
Do They Use HPP or Test & Hold?
These safety processes — often used in raw and gently cooked foods — aren’t relevant here, since American Journey only offers kibble and canned food. They do not use HPP or a test-and-hold protocol.
Do They Share a Full Nutritional Analysis?
Unfortunately, no. While basic guaranteed analysis is available, they do not provide a full nutrient profile including details like omega-3 content, amino acid levels, or mineral ratios. For those trying to customize diets or compare therapeutic values, this lack of data makes it harder to evaluate the food fully.
Final Thoughts
American Journey may be convenient and affordable, but if you’re looking for transparency, low-carb options, whole food ingredients, or minimally processed nutrition, there are better choices out there. Brands that prioritize fresh, raw, or gently cooked diets tend to avoid heavy starches, reduce synthetic additives, and focus on whole animal proteins your pet can actually thrive on.
If you’re on the journey to feeding better — whether it’s raw, cooked, or freeze-dried — there are incredible options that offer real transparency and species-appropriate nutrition.
Here are some that would be a huge upgrade for you:
Blue Buffalo is a well-known name in the commercial pet food world, often marketed as a wholesome, natural option with premium ingredients. But how does it really stack up when we dig into the details that matter for health-conscious pet parents?
Synthetic Vitamins
Yes, Blue Buffalo uses synthetic vitamins and minerals in most of their formulas. While this is common in kibble and canned foods, it does raise questions for pet owners who prefer whole-food nutrition. Synthetic vitamins are often less bioavailable and may be harder for pets to utilize efficiently, especially those with sensitivities.
Ingredient Quality
Blue Buffalo offers a range of formulas, including grain-free, limited ingredient, and high-protein lines. While the brand advertises “real meat first” and avoids poultry by-products in most lines, the actual ingredient quality is mixed. The use of rendered meals, like chicken or fish meal, and plant-based fillers such as peas, potatoes, tapioca, and alfalfa can dilute the nutritional value. Some lines also contain controversial ingredients like carrageenan in wet food.
Carbohydrate Content
Blue Buffalo’s dry foods tend to be high in carbohydrates — typically 30–45%, depending on the formula. This is due to their heavy reliance on starches such as brown rice, oatmeal, barley, peas, and potatoes. For carnivorous pets, especially cats and metabolically sensitive dogs, this can be problematic, potentially contributing to weight gain, inflammation, or blood sugar issues.
Sourcing & Transparency
Blue Buffalo does not disclose detailed sourcing information for their ingredients. While they claim to use only high-quality, natural ingredients, there is limited transparency about whether these are U.S.-sourced or imported. After a past lawsuit over misleading advertising (including claims about using no by-products), the brand’s trust factor among discerning pet owners took a hit.
Recalls
Blue Buffalo has had several recalls over the past 10+ years. Notably:
These incidents suggest ongoing quality control concerns, particularly with their manufacturing partners before the company was purchased by General Mills in 2018.
HPP or Test and Hold?
Blue Buffalo does not use High Pressure Processing (HPP) or any test-and-hold pathogen control method. This is largely because their products are not raw — they are cooked through extrusion (kibble) or canned. However, this also means less retention of natural nutrients and enzymes compared to raw or gently cooked options.
Do They Provide a Complete Nutritional Analysis?
Blue Buffalo provides AAFCO nutritional adequacy statements but does not publish full nutritional analyses (including micronutrient levels) on their website. For pet parents wanting transparency and to track nutrients like omega-3s, magnesium, phosphorus, or vitamin D, this lack of data can be frustrating.
Bottom Line
While Blue Buffalo may be a step up from some grocery store brands, it falls short for pet parents focused on species-appropriate, low-carb, transparently sourced nutrition. The use of synthetic additives, high carbohydrate content, and past recall history are worth considering. If you’re looking for a fresher, more biologically appropriate option, air baked, gently cooked or raw brands like Raised Right, Steve’s, Goodness Gracious, Evermore, Solutions Pet Food, All Provide, Dr. Harvey’s Raw Vibrance or CARNA4 may be a better fit.
When it comes to feeding our pets, not all kibbles — or even “natural” foods — are created equal. Most commercial dry foods rely on synthetic vitamins, low-quality ingredients, and heavy processing. But one company is doing things differently: Carna4.
Carna4 is one of the cleanest, most transparent pet foods available today. Designed to mimic the nutrition of a raw or fresh diet in a shelf-stable form, it skips the synthetic premix found in nearly every other pet food.
Here’s why we love Carna4 and why it’s one of the only air-dried or baked foods we truly stand behind.
No Synthetic Vitamins or Premix
Unlike most commercial brands, Carna4 meets AAFCO standards without synthetic additives. It uses sprouted seeds, liver, whole eggs, and other nutrient-dense foods to deliver naturally occurring vitamins and minerals — the way nature intended.
Human-Grade Ingredients
Every ingredient in Carna4 is thoughtfully sourced from trusted farms in Canada and the U.S. You won’t find feed-grade by-products or fillers here — just clean, whole foods like free-range chicken, wild-caught fish, and organic sprouted seeds.
Moderate Carbohydrates
Carna4 contains about 25–30% carbohydrates, mainly from whole sprouted grains and legumes. Unlike conventional kibble (which often exceeds 45–50% carbs), Carna4 keeps things more biologically appropriate for carnivores.
Test & Hold Safety (No HPP)
Instead of high-pressure processing (HPP), which can degrade food quality, Carna4 uses a gentle bake and test-and-hold protocol to ensure each batch is safe before it ships. This preserves nutrients while protecting your pet.
Zero Recalls. Ever.
That’s right — Carna4 has never had a recall. Not one. Their rigorous quality control and small-batch production speak volumes about their standards.
Nutritional Transparency
Carna4 provides a full nutritional breakdown on their website, so you know exactly what your pet is getting. Compare that to the vague guaranteed analyses you see from most brands, and the difference is clear.
If you’re looking for a clean, safe, and nutrient-dense food that’s ideal for sensitive dogs, picky eaters, or anyone transitioning off conventional kibble, Carna4 is worth every penny.
Order it here: CARNA4
Your pet’s body — and belly — will thank you.
Dr. Harvey’s is a trusted name in holistic pet nutrition. Their dehydrated base mixes let pet parents build fresh, balanced meals at home using real, human-grade ingredients without preservatives, fillers, or feed-grade by-products. Each mix is designed to support health naturally, whether your dog is thriving or facing serious health challenges.
Raw Vibrance
This is one of Dr. Harvey’s most popular formulas. It’s a grain-free, low-carb base mix made with 24 whole foods like broccoli, pumpkin seed, kelp, shiitake, and green-lipped mussel. It’s great for seniors, dogs with allergies, and those recovering from chronic conditions.
Paradigm
Paradigm is a true therapeutic formula designed as a ketogenic base mix. It supports dogs with cancer, epilepsy, diabetes, and inflammation. It includes kale, coconut, red bell pepper, hempseed, turmeric, and bone meal.
Canine Health
This is Dr. Harvey’s original base mix and includes organic grains like rolled oats and barley, plus vegetables and herbs. It’s best for dogs who tolerate grains well and don’t need a low-carb diet.
Veg-to-Bowl (Original and Fine Ground)
This grain-free vegetarian mix is perfect for dogs on elimination diets or those needing rotation proteins. It contains sweet potato, carrots, peas, and green beans.
Healthy Weight
A lower-calorie base mix designed for dogs needing to lose weight. It includes green beans, pumpkin, broccoli, and organic oats for fiber and satiety.
Herbal Supplements
Dr. Harvey’s also makes natural wellness blends like Golden Years, Relax, Immune Support, Allergy, and Kidney Health. These contain no synthetic ingredients and are made from herbs to gently support healing and balance.
Ingredient Quality
All products are made with human-grade, non-GMO ingredients in a human food facility. There are no fillers, by-products, rendered meals, or preservatives — just real food and herbs.
HPP or Test-and-Hold
Not applicable. Dr. Harvey’s mixes do not include meat, so there is no need for high-pressure processing or irradiation. You add your own fresh or raw protein at home.
Recalls
Dr. Harvey’s has never had a recall, as of August 2025. Their clean safety record reflects strong quality control and sourcing practices.
Nutritional Analysis
Yes, each product includes a complete guaranteed analysis on the Dr. Harvey’s website, with protein, fat, fiber, moisture, and calorie content.
Dr. Harvey’s is an excellent choice for pet parents who want to feed fresh food without guessing. If you’re avoiding synthetic vitamins, Raw Vibrance are great options. If your dog has serious health concerns, Paradigm offers therapeutic support with carefully added synthetics.
Dr. Judy Morgan and Saving Pets One Pet At a Time only recommend feeding Dr. Harvey Raw Vibrance or Paradigm. Each formula puts the power of fresh nutrition in your hands — making Dr. Harvey’s a strong ally for long-term wellness and healing.
You can order them here:
Dr. Marty’s pet food has made waves in the pet industry, often promoted as a premium, vet-developed, freeze-dried formula that supports longevity and optimal health. With the friendly face of Dr. Marty Goldstein — renowned holistic veterinarian — leading the brand, it’s no surprise that pet parents are curious. But when you look beyond the marketing, how does it actually stack up?
Let’s take a closer look at Dr. Marty’s formulas from a holistic and ingredient-conscious perspective.
Ingredients: A Good Start with Animal Proteins
Dr. Marty’s Nature’s Blend for dogs and cats starts off strong with animal-based ingredients like turkey, beef, salmon, duck, and organ meats. These species-appropriate proteins are what we love to see in a biologically correct pet diet. Organ meats, in particular, provide critical nutrients when they come from clean, well-sourced animals.
However, the formulas also include fruits and vegetables like sweet potato, apple, carrot, and blueberry. While these may sound nutritious, for some pets — especially those prone to yeast overgrowth, itching, or gut sensitivities — these starchy and sugary additions may not be ideal.
Does Dr. Marty’s Use HPP?
The answer? Unclear.
Dr. Marty’s does not publicly state whether they use High Pressure Pasteurization (HPP) on their freeze-dried food. While freeze-drying itself reduces the risk of pathogens, many reputable raw food brands still disclose whether their raw materials are HPP-treated or if they follow test-and-hold safety practices.
The lack of transparency around safety protocols like HPP or microbial testing is a concern for pet parents who want to know exactly how their pet’s food is handled from farm to bowl.
Carbohydrate Content: Higher Than You Might Expect
Even though Dr. Marty’s is freeze-dried raw, the carbohydrate content lands around 20–25% on a dry matter basis, depending on the formula. That’s considerably higher than most raw or gently cooked diets and may not suit pets with metabolic diseases, cancer, yeast infections, or obesity. This is largely due to the inclusion of sweet potatoes, apples, carrots, and other starches.
Do They Provide a Complete Nutritional Analysis?
No.
Dr. Marty’s does not provide a full nutrient panel on their website. While they list the guaranteed analysis (protein, fat, fiber, moisture), they do not offer detailed data on essential amino acids, vitamins, minerals, omega-3s, or caloric content per 1,000 kcal.
In contrast, brands like Raised Right, Steve’s Real Food, Carna4, and Solutions Pet Products provide full nutrient profiles and even lab results for transparency.
Recall History
As of mid-2025, Dr. Marty’s has not had any publicly reported recalls. That’s a good sign — but without transparency about their manufacturing facilities or food safety protocols, it’s hard to evaluate the full picture.
Final Thoughts
Dr. Marty’s may offer better ingredients than conventional kibble, but it falls short of the high standards set by top-tier raw and lightly cooked pet food brands. With higher carbs, no full nutrient panel, and unclear safety protocols, it’s worth pausing before assuming it’s the gold standard.
For pet parents seeking low-carb, fully transparent, whole food-based diets, you might want to consider options like:
These companies don’t just use high-quality ingredients — they show their work.
If you’ve been exploring pet food options, chances are you’ve come across the name Eukanuba. Known for their performance-focused dog food, Eukanuba has been a staple on pet store shelves for decades. But what’s really inside the bag — and does this brand cater to cats too? Let’s take a closer look.
Primarily for Dogs
Eukanuba is best known for its dog food. They offer a wide variety of formulas tailored to different breeds, sizes, life stages, and activity levels — from small breed puppies to senior large breeds. Their marketing often emphasizes “peak performance,” which appeals to working dogs and active pups.
Do They Make Cat Food?
Yes, Eukanuba has made cat food — but it’s not their primary focus. In fact, in many places, their feline line is hard to find or has been phased out. If you’re looking for a brand dedicated to cats and their unique nutritional needs, Eukanuba may not be the best fit.
Ingredient Quality
Eukanuba recipes typically start with a named meat (like chicken or lamb), but they quickly turn to lower-quality ingredients like corn meal, wheat, sorghum, and by-product meals. These formulas are high in carbohydrates, often 40–50% or more, which isn’t ideal for dogs — or especially cats, who are obligate carnivores.
Synthetic Additives
Like most kibble brands, Eukanuba uses synthetic vitamins and minerals to replace nutrients lost during high-heat processing. While that’s common, whole food-based nutrients are always more gentle and better absorbed by the body.
Sourcing & Transparency Eukanuba is owned by Mars Petcare, the same company behind Royal Canin and Pedigree. Unfortunately, they don’t offer much transparency about where their ingredients come from or how their foods are manufactured. For pet parents who value ingredient traceability and quality sourcing, this could be a red flag.
Recalls & Food Safety
Eukanuba had a notable recall in 2013 due to potential Salmonella contamination. While there haven’t been major incidents since, Mars Petcare has had recalls across several of their pet food brands. They also don’t use HPP (high pressure processing) or a test-and-hold process, both of which are common in higher-end raw or gently cooked foods.
Do They Share a Full Nutritional Analysis?
No, Eukanuba does not provide a complete nutrient panel on their website. While they do meet AAFCO standards, they don’t list detailed amounts of amino acids, vitamins, or minerals — something many pet parents now look for when evaluating food quality.
Final Thoughts
Eukanuba is a widely available, mainstream brand that may suit some dog owners looking for breed-specific kibble formulas. But if you’re searching for species-appropriate food made with whole ingredients, low carbs, and full transparency, you might want to look elsewhere — especially when it comes to cats.
If you’re ready to explore truly nourishing options for your furry companion, there are plenty of brands that go above and beyond in quality, transparency, and real food nutrition.
Here are our recommendations:
When it comes to feeding our pets, nothing feels better than knowing their meals are crafted with the same level of care we’d put into our own. That’s the philosophy behind Evermore Pet Food — a small, women-owned company focused on sourcing real, human-grade ingredients to nourish our furry family members.
But does Evermore truly live up to the hype? Let’s dig in.
Whole Food, Not Factory Waste
Evermore doesn’t cut corners. They use GAP-rated, pasture-raised beef and lamb, organic chicken, and antibiotic-free turkey — all humanely sourced from U.S. farms. There’s no rendered meals, no by-products, and no mystery meats. Just fresh muscle and organ meats, paired with organic vegetables like carrots, kale, and butternut squash.
These meals are gently cooked sous-vide, locking in nutrients while killing off harmful pathogens without the use of high-pressure processing (HPP). This cooking method keeps proteins digestible and nutrients intact—ideal for sensitive dogs or those recovering from illness.
Low Carbs, High Transparency
Evermore keeps carbohydrates in check, typically around 10–20% on a dry matter basis, depending on the recipe. Instead of high-glycemic fillers like white potatoes or grains, they use more nourishing options like squash and sweet potato in small amounts.
But what really sets Evermore apart? Their transparency. Every ingredient is listed with clear sourcing information. Their website even includes complete nutritional profiles for every formula — perfect for pet parents working with holistic vets or managing specific health conditions.
Safety First: Small Batch & Test + Hold
Unlike many large commercial brands, Evermore follows a test-and-hold protocol — meaning no food leaves their facility until it passes third-party testing for pathogens. And with zero recalls in their history, they’ve shown consistent care and quality control over the years.
Synthetic Vitamins? Minimal & Thoughtful
Evermore’s philosophy is to get as many nutrients as possible from whole food ingredients. That said, they do include minimal synthetic vitamins and minerals to ensure AAFCO compliance, but never as a shortcut. These additions are thoughtful and kept to a minimum.
Final Thoughts
If you’re looking for a clean, gently cooked, low-carb food backed by ethical sourcing, minimal processing, and complete transparency, Evermore Pet Food is an excellent choice.
Whether your dog is thriving or facing health challenges, Evermore offers a whole-food foundation you can trust.
You can get 15% off your first evermore order with coupon: SAVINGPETS.
When it comes to feeding your pets, every pet parent wants quality nutrition without breaking the bank. That’s exactly what 4Health — Tractor Supply Company’s in-house pet food brand — claims to offer. But does this “premium for less” kibble actually deliver on quality? Let’s take a closer look at the ingredients, transparency, and nutritional value of 4Health dog and cat food.
Quality of Ingredients 4Health dry foods for both dogs and cats usually start with a named meat (like chicken or salmon), which sounds promising. However, they often follow up with cheaper additions like pea protein, potato, powdered cellulose, and tomato pomace. These ingredients serve as fillers or fiber but aren’t biologically appropriate sources of nutrition for carnivores. The formulas rely on plant-heavy content that boosts protein and fiber numbers artificially, without offering the same digestibility or nutrient value as meat.
Carbohydrate Content
Most 4Health dry foods fall into the 35 – 45% carbohydrate range, which is quite high for both dogs and cats. Cats especially, as obligate carnivores, have no biological need for carbohydrates. High-carb diets can contribute to obesity, inflammation, and chronic health issues over time.
Synthetic Vitamins and Minerals
As with many kibbles, 4Health uses synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes to meet AAFCO nutrient standards. There’s little to no use of whole food-based nutrients, and this can impact the bioavailability of the nutrients your pet actually absorbs. For sensitive pets or those with chronic conditions, synthetic-heavy formulations may not support optimal health.
Sourcing and Transparency
4Health is manufactured by Diamond Pet Foods, a large private-label manufacturer that also makes food for many other store brands. The company has limited transparency, offering no detailed ingredient sourcing information. While the label might say “USA made,” it doesn’t clarify where individual ingredients come from — and many of them are globally sourced, possibly including from China.
Recalls and Manufacturing
Concerns
4Health has had two major recalls in recent years:
These recalls highlight concerns about quality control in large-scale manufacturing.
Do They Use HPP or Test-and-Hold?
No. 4Health does not use high-pressure processing (HPP) or a test-and-hold protocol. The food is mass-produced and distributed through commercial chains, without the same safety assurance found in many smaller, holistic pet food brands.
Do They Provide a Complete Nutritional Analysis? Unfortunately, no. 4Health only provides the basic guaranteed analysis (protein, fat, fiber, moisture), which is not enough to evaluate the full nutritional value of the food. There’s no detailed nutrient breakdown — no vitamin, mineral, amino acid, or fatty acid profiles. That makes it hard to assess whether the food truly supports long-term health or just meets minimum standards.
Is There a Cat Food Line?
Yes, 4Health offers both dry and wet cat food, and it’s priced affordably. The canned recipes are generally lower in carbohydrates than the kibble and contain animal-based proteins and organ meats. Still, the same concerns apply: limited transparency, use of synthetic vitamins, and lack of a full nutritional profile.
Final Thoughts
4Health may look like a step up from the cheapest grocery store brands, and it does exclude corn, soy, and wheat. But under the surface, it relies on inexpensive ingredients, synthetic nutrients, high carbohydrates, and minimal transparency. For pets with allergies, sensitivities, or chronic health needs, it’s far from ideal. If you’re looking to feed your pet a species-appropriate diet with low carbs, whole-food nutrients, and clearly sourced ingredients, there are much better options out there — especially in the raw, gently cooked, or freeze-dried categories.
We recommend you purchase one of these foods instead:
If you’ve walked down the dog food aisle or browsed online pet retailers, chances are you’ve seen Gentle Giants — a kibble brand co-founded by actor Burt Ward (Robin from the original Batman series). It’s marketed as a longevity-boosting food that helped rescue dogs in their sanctuary live into their 20s. Sounds amazing, right? But let’s dig into the details to see if Gentle Giants lives up to the hype.
What’s in the Bag?
Gentle Giants does have a few things going for it — it avoids by-products, artificial preservatives, and dyes, which are all common in conventional kibbles. But when we look closely at the ingredients, the first thing that jumps out is carbohydrates. Lots of them.
With ingredients like brown rice, oatmeal, barley, and white rice making up the bulk of the formula, this kibble can contain over 40% carbs, sometimes more. Dogs, especially those with allergies, chronic conditions, or yeast issues, tend to thrive on low-carb, meat-based diets. High-carb formulas may work for some, but they’re not ideal for most dogs — especially if you’re aiming for longevity and optimal health.
Do They Use Synthetic Vitamins?
Yes. Like nearly all kibbles, Gentle Giants relies on synthetic vitamins and minerals to meet AAFCO nutrient profiles. These synthetic additives help fill nutritional gaps in processed foods, but they aren’t the same as nutrients found naturally in whole food. Over time, this may contribute to inflammation or nutrient imbalances in sensitive dogs.
What About Quality and Transparency?
Here’s where things get murkier. Gentle Giants doesn’t provide much information about ingredient sourcing or manufacturing standards. There’s no mention of where their meats come from, whether they test for pesticides or heavy metals, or how they ensure ingredient integrity. For a brand that claims to promote health and longevity, this lack of transparency is disappointing.
They also don’t offer a complete nutritional analysis on their website. You’ll find the standard guaranteed analysis (protein, fat, fiber, moisture), but there’s no detailed breakdown of amino acids, vitamins, or minerals to help pet parents make truly informed decisions.
Safety Track Record
The good news is that Gentle Giants has not had any recalls to date. That’s always a plus. However, there’s also no mention of a test-and-hold safety protocol, which means we don’t know if they test batches for pathogens before releasing them to the public.
The Bottom Line
While Gentle Giants is marketed as a healthy, affordable kibble for longevity, it still falls into the high-carb, synthetic-heavy, low-transparency category that defines most dry dog foods. It may be a step up from ultra-processed supermarket brands, but it’s far from the gold standard in pet nutrition.
If you’re looking for options that prioritize low-carb, whole-food ingredients, transparency, and food safety, you might want to explore:
Every pet deserves the best. When we know better, we do better — and our pets thrive.
When it comes to feeding our pets, transparency, quality, and species-appropriate nutrition matter more than ever. Goodness Gracious, a small-batch pet food company based in Massachusetts, has earned a solid reputation for delivering all three.
Let’s take a closer look at what makes this brand stand out — and why it may be one of the best choices for pets with food sensitivities, chronic illness, or anyone simply looking to feed their dog or cat better.
Whole-Food Ingredients with No Synthetic Vitamins
Unlike most commercial brands that rely on synthetic vitamin premixes to meet nutritional standards, Goodness Gracious takes a truly whole-food approach. Every ingredient is there for a reason and serves a nutritional purpose. That means no synthetic additives, no feed-grade ingredients, and no mystery meat meals.
Their recipes are made with USDA-inspected, human-edible proteins, like grass-fed beef, pasture-raised turkey, and wild-caught fish. Fruits and vegetables are organic when possible and always fresh — not dried powders or shelf-stable blends. If your pet has allergies or sensitivities, these clean, whole-food formulas offer a gentle and nourishing alternative.
Low Carbohydrate Content
Carbohydrates are often the hidden culprits behind inflammation, yeast, and weight gain in pets. Goodness Gracious keeps carbs impressively low across most of their recipes. On average:
This low-carb focus makes them a strong option for dogs with cancer, diabetes, or yeast issues, as well as cats who naturally thrive on very low-carbohydrate diets.
Made in Their Own USDA-Inspected Facility
Everything is made in-house in their Massachusetts facility — not outsourced to a large co-packer. That means complete control over sourcing, preparation, and safety. They follow a test-and-hold protocol, which means every batch is tested for pathogens like Salmonella, Listeria, and E. coli before it’s released.
And no—they don’t use HPP (high-pressure pasteurization), which helps preserve the natural enzymes and structure of raw food. This is important for pets relying on raw nutrition for gut health and immune support.
Full Nutritional Transparency
Many brands only provide the basics, but Goodness Gracious goes further. They offer:
This kind of transparency is a game changer — especially for pet parents working with holistic vets or needing precise nutrient tracking for chronic health conditions.
Zero Recalls and a Commitment to Clean Food
With zero recalls to date and a truly small-batch model, Goodness Gracious shows that you don’t need to compromise safety for quality. Their entire philosophy is rooted in feeding pets the same clean, real food we’d want for ourselves.
The Bottom Line
If you’re looking for a brand that avoids synthetic vitamins, keeps carbs low, and offers unmatched transparency, Goodness Gracious (for dogs and cats) delivers. Their clean ingredient lists, test-and-hold protocols, and whole-food-based recipes make them one of the most trustworthy choices for raw and gently cooked feeding.
Have a pet with allergies, sensitivities, or chronic illness? This might be the brand to try next.
Want help comparing specific recipes or building a transition plan for your pet? Reach out anytime — they are happy to help.
You can order here:
Goodness Gracious (for dogs and cats)
When your pet is struggling with a health issue, there’s a good chance your vet has recommended Hill’s Science Diet. Marketed as “biology-based nutrition,” Hill’s is one of the most prescribed lines of pet food in traditional veterinary clinics. But if you’re committed to feeding species-appropriate, whole food diets — or at least understanding what goes into your pet’s bowl — it’s important to take a closer look.
Let’s break it down.
High Carbs in a Carnivore’s Bowl?
Despite being labeled as “scientifically formulated,” Hill’s Science Diet is extremely high in carbohydrates. On average, their dry kibble formulas contain 40–55% carbs on a dry matter basis.
That’s a lot of starch for a species that thrives on animal protein and fat. Instead of fresh meat or organ-based energy, these carbs come from:
These are not only biologically inappropriate for dogs and cats, but they’re also high-glycemic, meaning they can spike blood sugar, feed yeast, and promote inflammation. Over time, this may contribute to chronic conditions like diabetes, obesity, itchy skin, and poor gut health.
What About Ingredient Quality?
One of the biggest concerns with Hill’s is the low quality of its ingredients:
There’s little to no organ meat, no fresh muscle meats as the main ingredient, and few nutrient-dense animal fats. Instead, Hill’s relies heavily on processed grains and by-products that don’t support optimal vitality.
These are not human-grade ingredients, and the brand makes no effort to source from pasture-raised, antibiotic-free, or non-GMO suppliers.
Synthetic Vitamins: A Nutritional Crutch
To meet AAFCO standards, Hill’s relies on a long list of synthetic vitamins and minerals, including:
These aren’t inherently bad, but in a diet made from whole, fresh food, many of these nutrients should be coming naturally from organs, meats, and bone — not from a lab.
Synthetic premixes may help prevent deficiency, but they can’t replace the bioavailable nutrients and enzymes found in real food.
Where Do They Source Their Ingredients?
Hill’s is very vague when it comes to ingredient sourcing. We know that their foods are manufactured in their own U.S.-based facilities, but:
For pet parents who prioritize transparency, this lack of sourcing detail is a red flag.
Do They Use HPP or Test-and-Hold Safety Methods?
Because Hill’s Science Diet is a heavily processed kibble, it’s cooked at extremely high temperatures (called extrusion), which destroys bacteria — along with many beneficial nutrients.
That means they do not use HPP (High Pressure Processing) or raw food safety systems like test-and-hold. These safety measures are more common in raw or gently cooked brands that want to preserve nutrient integrity while keeping the food pathogen-free.
So while Hill’s may be sterile, it’s also lifeless and void of the natural enzymes, amino acids, and living nutrients that fresh food can provide.
In Summary: Is Hill’s Science Diet Right for Your Pet?
From a holistic perspective, Hill’s Science Diet doesn’t deliver what our pets truly need to thrive:
While it may be recommended in vet clinics, Hill’s is not a brand that aligns with fresh food philosophy or holistic pet wellness. If your goal is to nourish your pet with whole, nutrient-dense food that supports longevity, gut health, and a resilient immune system — there are far better options available.
Better Options:
For years, Nature’s Logic has been a standout in the pet food world, earning the trust of holistic pet parents for its commitment to whole-food nutrition without synthetic vitamins or minerals. Their formulas are built from real meat, organ meats, fruits, vegetables, kelp, and montmorillonite clay — never relying on artificial nutrients or common fillers.
But after being acquired by Mid America Pet Food in 2021, many in the pet nutrition community are wondering: Will Nature’s Logic stay the same?
Whole Food Formulas — Still Intact (for Now)
Nature’s Logic has always taken the road less traveled in the pet food industry. Instead of lab-made vitamins, they pull nutrients from whole food ingredients such as liver, pumpkin seed, spinach, kelp, and blueberries. Their recipes avoid peas, lentils, potatoes, soy, corn, and wheat. As of today, the brand has not changed its recipes post-acquisition and they still stand out as one of the cleanest options in the kibble and canned categories.
The Carbohydrate Factor
Even with their clean ingredients, Nature’s Logic kibble is relatively high in carbohydrates — around 35 – 40% — primarily from millet. While millet is less inflammatory than many grains, this level is not ideal for dogs dealing with yeast, cancer, diabetes, or obesity. Their canned foods are much lower in carbs (5 – 10%) and better suited for dogs who need a lower-glycemic diet. For raw and gently cooked feeders, the canned versions make a more species-appropriate backup.
Who is Mid America Pet Food?
Mid America Pet Food is the company behind brands like Victor, Eagle Mountain, and Wayne Feeds. They are not linked to the massive aflatoxin recall that plagued Midwestern Pet Foods in 2020 – 2021, but as with any corporate buyout, the concern is whether small-batch quality and sourcing will remain the same. Mid America has stated that they plan to keep Nature’s Logic’s core values and whole-food formulas intact. However, holistic advocates recommend keeping a close eye on ingredient sourcing and nutritional profiles over time.
Sourcing, Transparency & Manufacturing
Nature’s Logic continues to source meat from the USA, New Zealand, and Europe, produce and nutrient-rich whole foods from North America, and manufacture in USDA-inspected facilities in the USA. They’ve maintained their transparent labeling and nutrient disclosures, something not all brands do.
HPP or Test & Hold?
Nature’s Logic products are cooked (either extruded kibble or canned), so they do not use High Pressure Processing (HPP). The company does not publicly state if they use a “test and hold” program for pathogen control, which is more relevant for raw foods but still a factor in food safety protocols.
Nutritional Analysis Availability
Yes — Nature’s Logic provides a complete nutrient profile for each recipe on their website, including dry matter basis and caloric details. This is a strong plus for transparency.
Final Thoughts
Nature’s Logic is a decent alternative for pet parents who want an alternative to kibble. However, based on the ingredients we would only feel comfortable feeding Nature’s Logic Distinction. That said, corporate acquisitions often lead to slow shifts in sourcing or formulation. While Mid America Pet Food has not made changes so far, pet parents should continue to watch the brand’s ingredient lists and nutritional disclosures closely. History shows that when pet food companies are acquired their quality often is degraded.
Other foods you may want to consider instead:
Oma’s Pride is a family-owned pet food company with roots going back to the 1950s. Known for their raw and gently cooked diets, they offer a wide range of options for dogs and cats using quality animal-based ingredients. Based in Connecticut, they’ve earned a reputation in the raw feeding community for their long history, consistent availability, and commitment to species-appropriate food — but there are a few important details to be aware of when evaluating the line.
Oma’s Pride uses USDA-inspected, human-grade meats sourced mostly from the United States. Their meals contain a mix of muscle meat, organs, raw bone, and sometimes green tripe, which gives a natural balance of nutrients. Their products are also free from grains, legumes, by-products, and artificial preservatives.
Unlike some raw brands that avoid all synthetics, Oma’s Pride does use synthetic vitamins and minerals in several of their “complete” formulas. While these additions help them meet AAFCO nutritional standards, it’s a detail worth noting if you prefer a diet balanced exclusively with whole foods. The company also offers “basic” and “blend” lines without added vitamins, designed to be part of a DIY approach or fed with supplementation.
The average carbohydrate content in their raw meals is very low — typically under 2% on a dry matter basis. There are no starchy fillers like potatoes, peas, or lentils, making Oma’s Pride a suitable choice for pets with metabolic issues or yeast overgrowth.
Oma’s Pride does not use high-pressure processing (HPP). Instead, they follow a test-and-hold protocol for safety, meaning every batch is tested for pathogens like salmonella before being released. This approach preserves the natural enzymes and beneficial bacteria found in raw food while maintaining quality control.
When it comes to transparency, Oma’s Pride does a solid job. They own their manufacturing facility and do not use co-packers. This gives them full control over sourcing and production. While they don’t disclose exact farm names or every sourcing detail, they offer more transparency than many large commercial brands.
As of today, Oma’s Pride has had one voluntary recall in the last decade. In 2021, a batch of raw cat food was recalled due to a potential salmonella risk. The issue was resolved promptly and limited in scope, reflecting their commitment to food safety.
Their website provides typical nutritional analyses for each product, including crude protein, fat, moisture, and fiber. However, a full breakdown of all essential vitamins and minerals is not always available online, which may be a drawback for some pet parents looking for complete transparency.
In summary, Oma’s Pride is a respected name in the raw feeding world with a long-standing reputation, high-quality meats, and low-carb formulations. However, for those seeking a truly whole food – only diet with no synthetics, their use of added vitamins in certain formulas is something to keep in mind. Their lack of HPP, test-and-hold safety model, and family-owned production facility are all strong positives. Oma’s Pride is a solid, accessible raw option for many pet parents, especially those just starting to explore raw feeding or who prefer a mix of DIY and complete meals.
Oma’s Pride is on Susan Thixton’s 2025 Truth About Pet Food Recommended Food List and has met her rigorous standards. It is good food but if you want food that has no or minimal synthetic vitamins in it we recommend:
More and more pet parents are leaving kibble behind and looking for truly nourishing food made with real, raw ingredients. PawTree has entered the freeze-dried and raw pet food space with bold claims of better nutrition and customized solutions. But does it really deliver when it comes to transparency, quality, and species-appropriate ingredients?
Let’s break it down from a holistic, whole-food perspective.
Quality of Ingredients: Some Hits, Some Misses
PawTree’s freeze-dried meals typically lead with real meats like turkey, beef, chicken, or lamb, and often include organs and ground bone—an excellent start. But they also add plant-based ingredients like:
While these may be marketed as “superfoods,” they introduce unnecessary starch and sugar into a carnivore’s diet. Pets with yeast issues, skin flare-ups, or IBD often do best on diets with minimal plant content — and PawTree isn’t low plant by any means.
Carbohydrate Content: Higher Than Ideal
Using the guaranteed analysis from a typical freeze-dried recipe (e.g., Turkey & Sweet Potato), we estimate the carbohydrate content around 15% (dry matter basis). That’s considerably higher than more carnivore-focused brands, especially those designed for pets with inflammation or metabolic concerns.
For comparison:
PawTree’s use of sweet potatoes, carrots, and fruit drives up the sugar and starch load — something to consider for pets on anti-yeast, cancer-supportive, or low-glycemic protocols.
Synthetic Vitamins: Yes, They’re Used
PawTree does use a standard synthetic vitamin and mineral premix, including ingredients like:
This is common among freeze-dried foods, but it also means that nutrients aren’t coming entirely from whole food sources. Brands like Small Batch and Evermore either use minimal synthetics or rely more heavily on nutrient-dense, whole food ingredients.
Sourcing & Transparency: Limited Insight
While PawTree states that their products are made in the U.S., they do not disclose detailed sourcing information — such as where the meat is raised, whether produce is organic, or whether their supplements are tested for purity.
They also do not mention any third-party testing for:
In contrast, Raised Right, Solutions Pet Food, Goodness Gracious, Steve’s Pet Food, Evermore, and Small Batch publish full lab results and sourcing details, giving pet parents confidence in both safety and quality.
Do They Use HPP or a Test-and-Hold Protocol?
PawTree does not specify whether they use High Pressure Pasteurization (HPP) on their raw or freeze-dried food. They also don’t mention if they use a test-and-hold safety protocol to screen for pathogens before shipping.
Brands like All Provide and Steve’s Real Food are open about their food safety practices, while Solutions Pet Food uses fermentation as a natural pathogen control and avoids HPP entirely.
Do They Publish a Full Nutritional Analysis?
No, PawTree only provides a basic guaranteed analysis — protein, fat, fiber, and moisture. They do not publish a full nutrient panel with amino acids, vitamins, or minerals. For pet parents working with a holistic vet or managing specific health conditions, this lack of data can be limiting.
Compare this to Goodness Gracious, Steve’s Pet Food, Evermore, Raised Right and Small Batch all of which provide full nutritional panels and batch-level transparency.
Recall History: None Reported To Date
PawTree has had no recalls, which is a positive sign. Still, transparency around safety protocols would help further reassure consumers.
Final Thoughts: Where PawTree Stands
PawTree’s freeze-dried and raw meals are a step up from processed kibble and do include high-quality meats. But when you look deeper, the brand falls short of holistic, low-carb, and full transparency standards.
The inclusion of sweet potatoes, fruits, and synthetic vitamins bumps them into a mid-tier category — better than most mass-market foods, but not quite ideal for those seeking the cleanest, most species-appropriate nutrition.
If you’re looking for truly low-carb, whole-food-based nutrition with transparent sourcing and minimal processing, these brands are better aligned with a holistic philosophy:
Bottom Line: PawTree has moderate carbohydrates. They have meat as their main ingredient and then some cheap fillers and many synthetic vitamins. Pets should get their vitamins naturally in their food not added in. Also, PawTree’s lack of transparency when it comes to sourcing and their lack of a complete nutritional analysis is concerning.
We recommend you purchase one of these foods instead:
If you’re on a mission to feed your dog or cat real, clean food — Raised Right might just be what you’ve been searching for. In a market flooded with ultra-processed kibble, questionable ingredients, and synthetic vitamin cocktails, this brand stands out in all the best ways.
Human-Grade and Gently Cooked — Just Like You’d Make at Home
Raised Right meals are gently cooked in USDA-inspected kitchens using only human-grade ingredients. Think single-source proteins like turkey, beef, or pork — paired with small amounts of whole veggies like carrots or cranberries. That’s it. No grains, no fillers, and no garbage.
But what really makes them unique? They don’t use synthetic vitamins. Nearly every pet food company (even the premium ones) adds a vitamin premix made in a lab. Raised Right skips that entirely, relying instead on whole food sources like liver, egg, cod liver oil, and organic herbs to deliver nutrients the way nature intended.
Ultra Low-Carb for Pets Who Thrive on Protein and Fat
Most commercial dog and cat foods contain 30-60% carbohydrates — even some marketed as “grain-free.” Raised Right is different. Their recipes contain less than 2% carbs on average, making them ideal for pets with:
This species-appropriate approach supports blood sugar balance, reduces inflammation, and helps restore gut health.
Safety Without HPP (High Pressure Processing)
Raised Right does not use HPP, a common method used by many raw and fresh food brands that can degrade the structure of meat and impact nutrient availability. Instead, they gently cook the food to safe temperatures, then:
Transparency You Can Trust
One of the most refreshing things about Raised Right is their radical transparency. Every batch they produce can be traced by lot number on their website. They even publish third-party lab results publicly. That’s a level of openness that’s rare in the pet food industry.
They also worked with some of the most respected names in holistic pet nutrition — including Dr. Karen Becker and Steve Brown — to develop recipes that meet AAFCO standards using only real food.
No Recalls. Ever.
With many “vet-recommended” foods having multiple recalls over the years, Raised Right’s zero-recall history speaks volumes about their quality control.
The Bottom Line
Raised Right isn’t just another pet food company — it’s a return to common sense feeding. If you want to nourish your dog or cat with clean, whole, limited ingredients — and skip the synthetic additives — this brand deserves a place in your freezer.
Whether your pet struggles with allergies, chronic illness, or you simply want to give them the best, Raised Right offers peace of mind in every bite.
You can get 20% off the first 16 bags of Raised Right Pet Food using coupon code: PETS 20.
Saving pets, one meal at a time.
When it comes to feeding our pets, most of us want more than just a “vet-recommended” label. We want to know what’s in the food, where it comes from, and how it impacts our pets’ long-term health. One of the biggest names in the pet food world is Royal Canin — but does it truly live up to the hype?
Let’s take a closer look through a holistic lens.
High in Carbohydrates
Most Royal Canin formulas — especially dry kibble — contain 35–50% carbohydrates on a dry matter basis. Ingredients like brewers rice, corn, wheat, and soy derivatives are commonly used, which aren’t ideal for carnivores. For pets with health concerns like diabetes, IBD, yeast overgrowth, or inflammation, this high-carb load can be problematic.
Ingredient Quality: More About Process Than Purity
Royal Canin uses terms like “by-product meal” and “hydrolyzed soy protein isolate,” which are ultra-processed and far from whole, species-appropriate foods. While these ingredients meet AAFCO standards, they’re often rejected by holistic veterinarians and raw feeders due to their inflammatory potential and lack of transparency.
Instead of human-grade meats and organs, many Royal Canin diets rely on:
Synthetic Vitamins Over Whole Foods
Because these diets are cooked at extremely high temperatures, nutrients are destroyed and must be added back in. That means Royal Canin relies heavily on synthetic vitamins and minerals to meet nutritional minimums.
You’ll often see ingredients like:
Whole food-based brands usually derive nutrients from ingredients like bone, liver, kelp, and egg yolk — offering better bioavailability and fewer risks of nutrient imbalance.
Sourcing & Transparency: Still a Mystery
Royal Canin offers very little transparency about the origin of their ingredients. While they state that they source globally and manufacture in multiple countries, they don’t reveal:
In contrast, small batch and human-grade pet food companies often disclose this openly on their websites and packaging.
Recall History
Royal Canin has had a few recalls, including:
While not a frequent offender, the brand has had serious issues in the past—especially involving synthetic vitamin imbalances.
Do They Offer a Complete Nutritional Analysis?
No. Royal Canin does not provide a full nutrient profile on their website. You’ll only find the basic guaranteed analysis — which includes protein, fat, fiber, and moisture — but no detailed vitamin, mineral, or amino acid breakdown.
If you want to know how much manganese, taurine, iodine, or magnesium is in their food, you’ll have to contact them directly or go through your vet. This lack of transparency makes it hard to evaluate their diets for pets with medical conditions or unique needs.
Final Thoughts: Is Royal Canin Right for Your Pet?
If your priority is whole-food, species-appropriate nutrition with transparent sourcing, low carbohydrate content, and real ingredients you can pronounce, Royal Canin likely isn’t the best match.
It’s a convenient, mass-market product that relies on synthetic nutrients and processed ingredients rather than whole food nutrition. For pet parents seeking a more natural, holistic approach, there are far better options available—from raw and gently cooked diets to freeze-dried and human-grade brands that put quality first.
Your pet deserves more than a prescription bag of mystery ingredients. Feed with intention. Choose transparency. And always read beyond the label.
Here are pet foods that can help keep your dog or cat healthy:
When it comes to feeding our pets the very best, Smallbatch stands out as a brand committed to whole food, biologically appropriate nutrition. Known for their small-batch production, locally sourced ingredients, and minimal processing, they offer both frozen raw and gently cooked formulas that appeal to pet parents seeking a holistic, transparent approach to feeding.
But how does it measure up in key areas like ingredient quality, safety, carb content, and synthetic additives? Let’s take a closer look.
Thoughtfully Sourced, Clean Ingredients
Smallbatch uses pasture-raised or free-range meats that are hormone- and antibiotic-free. All animal proteins are humanely sourced from U.S. farms, primarily in California. Produce is certified organic, and you won’t find grains, legumes, or synthetic preservatives in any of their foods. Their commitment to sourcing sets them apart from most commercial pet food brands.
Instead of filler ingredients, Smallbatch uses functional whole foods like organic dandelion and rosemary, raw ground bone, organic kelp, and raw apple cider vinegar. This makes their formulas both nutritious and easy to digest, especially for pets with allergies or sensitive systems.
No Synthetic Vitamins in Raw — Minimal in Cooked
Here’s where the distinction matters. The frozen raw formulas (sliders and patties) are 100% free of synthetic vitamins and minerals. They rely solely on nutrient-dense whole foods to provide naturally occurring vitamins, minerals, and trace elements.
The gently cooked line includes a few minimal synthetic nutrients such as zinc proteinate, vitamin E supplement, and thiamine mononitrate (Vitamin B1). These are likely added to meet AAFCO minimums for adult dogs. That said, Smallbatch chooses high-quality, bioavailable forms — not cheap or inflammatory synthetics like copper sulfate or zinc oxide. It’s a gentle compromise for those who want lightly cooked food that still meets nutritional standards.
Low Carbohydrates Across the Board
One of the strongest features of Smallbatch is its low-carb formulation. Most frozen raw recipes average 2–4% carbohydrates on a dry matter basis, making them ideal for pets with metabolic issues, yeast, cancer, or those thriving on an ancestral diet.
Even the gently cooked recipes keep carbs relatively low compared to most commercial cooked options. You won’t find starchy fillers or high-glycemic ingredients here.
Safety Standards: No HPP, But Test & Hold
Unlike many commercial raw brands, Smallbatch does not use High Pressure Pasteurization (HPP). HPP can denature proteins and damage delicate nutrients in raw food, which goes against their philosophy of keeping food as natural as possible.
Instead, they use a test-and-hold protocol. Every batch is lab-tested for Salmonella, E. coli, and Listeria, and food is only released once it passes safety testing. This method protects nutrient integrity while still keeping safety a top priority.
Transparency & Track Record
Smallbatch is highly transparent about sourcing and production practices. They publish ingredients, feeding guidelines, and guaranteed analyses for each formula. For some proteins, they offer a more detailed nutrient breakdown, and you can request full nutrient profiles directly from the company if needed.
As of mid-2025, Smallbatch has had only one recall, back in 2016 for a single batch of chicken blend due to possible Salmonella. Since then, they’ve maintained a clean safety record.
Final Thoughts
Smallbatch is a standout in the pet food world for its commitment to humanely raised, local ingredients, organic produce, whole food nutrition, low carbs, test-and-hold safety, and transparent business practices. If you’re looking for a raw or gently cooked food that avoids cheap fillers and synthetic additives, Smallbatch is one of the cleanest options out there. While their gently cooked formulas include a few minimal synthetics, they’re carefully chosen and used sparingly making this brand a strong contender for both raw and cooked feeders.
You can get Small Batch on Amazon:
OR
You may want to explore more holistic brands like:
If you’re looking for a raw pet food brand that stays true to the philosophy of species-appropriate nutrition, Steve’s Real Food is a name that deserves your attention. With a clean ingredient panel, low carbohydrate content, and a commitment to transparency, Steve’s offers one of the most thoughtfully crafted raw diets on the market today.
Let’s take a closer look at what makes this brand a trusted favorite among holistic pet parents.
No Synthetic Vitamins – Just Real Food Nutrition
One of the most impressive things about Steve’s Real Food is what they don’t include: no synthetic vitamins or minerals. Instead, they rely on whole food ingredients — like goat milk, chia seed, kelp, and raw bone — to meet nutritional standards naturally. Their recipes are formulated to meet AAFCO standards using nothing artificial, which makes their food highly bioavailable and easier for pets to digest.
Low Carbohydrate, High-Quality Nutrition
Most commercial pet foods — especially kibble — are loaded with carbohydrates that dogs and cats don’t need. Steve’s formulas come in at only 1–5% carbohydrates on a dry matter basis, depending on the specific protein. That makes this food an ideal choice for pets struggling with issues like yeast overgrowth, cancer, diabetes, and obesity, where low-carb diets can make a huge difference.
Ingredient Sourcing and Transparency
Steve’s is incredibly transparent about where their ingredients come from. Their meats are pasture-raised or grass-fedand sourced from family farms in the USA, primarily in the Pacific Northwest. They use humanely raised, USDA-inspected meats, and their produce is pesticide-free. They even break down their sourcing and safety practices right on their website — something most pet food companies still fail to do.
Do They HPP?
While many raw feeders seek food that’s as unprocessed as possible, it’s important to know that Steve’s Real Food does use High Pressure Processing (HPP) on all their raw frozen and freeze-dried diets.
HPP is a cold-pressure pasteurization method that uses extremely high water pressure to kill pathogens like Salmonella and E. coli without the use of heat. It’s generally considered a safer option for households with young children, seniors, or immunocompromised individuals. However, it can impact beneficial bacteria, natural enzymes, and the living qualities of raw food, which is why many holistic pet parents prefer non-HPP brands.
If you’re committed to truly unprocessed raw, you may want to explore brands that use a test-and-hold method instead, such as Viva Raw, SmallBatch (some lines), or Answers.
Recall History
In over two decades, Steve’s Real Food has had only one voluntary recall, back in 2018 for potential salmonella contamination. Since then, they’ve implemented even stricter safety protocols. Their excellent track record gives pet parents confidence that they take food safety seriously without compromising on quality.
Complete Nutritional Analysis Available
Steve’s doesn’t leave you guessing when it comes to what’s in their food. They provide a complete nutritional analysisfor each formula, including:
This transparency is invaluable for pet parents managing specific health conditions or working with veterinary nutritionists.
The Bottom Line
Steve’s Real Food is one of the few raw brands that checks all the boxes: clean sourcing, whole food nutrition, no synthetic additives, minimal processing, and full transparency. Their low-carb, unadulterated raw diets are an excellent choice for pet parents looking to support their dog or cat’s health through biologically appropriate nutrition.
If you’re new to raw feeding or looking for a brand to trust, Steve’s Real Food is a solid place to start. You can get 5% off for first time customers AND 10% off every subscription. Use coupon code: SAVINGPETS at Steve’s Real food.
When it comes to feeding your pet a truly clean, whole-food diet, The Simple Food Project delivers on its promise — simple, real ingredients with nothing synthetic or questionable in the bag. Founded by holistic veterinarian Dr. Bessent, this brand is rooted in the belief that pets thrive on species-appropriate nutrition made from recognizable, nutrient-dense foods.
So what sets The Simple Food Project apart from the rest?
Whole Food Ingredients, Not Synthetic Additives
Many freeze-dried pet foods use synthetic vitamins and minerals to meet nutritional standards, but The Simple Food Project takes a different approach. Every nutrient in their food is derived from whole, real food — like beef heart, duck liver, kale, and mussels. There are no isolated or synthetic vitamins, which is a huge win for pets with sensitivities and for those wanting a truly natural diet.
Low Carbohydrate and Ancestral Nutrition
Their recipes are high in protein and healthy fats, with an average of under 10% carbohydrates on a dry matter basis. You won’t find fillers like peas, lentils, rice, or corn here. Instead, carbs come from small, nutrient-rich additions like pumpkin or apples. This makes the food highly digestible and ideal for dogs that do best on low-carb diets.
Sourced with Integrity
Transparency matters — and The Simple Food Project makes it easy to see exactly what you’re feeding. Ingredients are human-grade and responsibly sourced. All meats are raised without antibiotics or hormones, fish are wild-caught, and most ingredients are U.S.-sourced, with the exception of green-lipped mussels from New Zealand. Their full ingredient lists are published clearly on their website.
Freeze-Dried for Safety & Convenience
While they don’t use HPP (high-pressure processing), their freeze-drying process eliminates pathogens while preserving raw nutrition and flavor. This means you get the benefits of a raw diet without the prep work or mess. Just scoop and serve. They don’t explicitly mention a test-and-hold protocol, but freeze-drying is already a known pathogen-reduction step.
Clean Recall Record
Safety-conscious pet parents will appreciate that The Simple Food Project has had zero recalls to date. That’s no small feat in the pet food world and reflects their commitment to quality control.
Complete Nutritional Transparency
Yes — they do provide a complete nutritional analysis on their website for each recipe, including calorie content, macronutrient breakdown, and essential vitamins and minerals (all derived from food).
Final Thoughts
If you’re looking for a freeze-dried food that mirrors a raw, ancestral diet without synthetic ingredients or high carb fillers, The Simple Food Project is a brand worth considering. It’s thoughtfully formulated, easy to use, and packed with nutrition you can trust.
Whether you’re transitioning from kibble or just want to simplify raw feeding without compromising on quality, this brand makes it easy to feed your pet the way nature intended — simply. You can order your Simple Food Project here:
We’ve poured our hearts into creating this website for you, and we’re still bustling with excitement to keep it going! As a team of volunteers, we’re using our own resources to bring this information to life. There are many ways you can show your support for our efforts. We greatly appreciate it! If we’ve been able to help you on your journey to a healthier pet, we would love it if you consider showing your support.
