Theme shot of a picky eater dog in kitchen with a plate of food.
Picky Eaters

Fur-ocious Appetites: Ending Pet Mealtime Battles

Some pets dive into their food bowls like it’s the best part of the day, while others give you that look — the one that says, “Nice try, but I’m not eating this.” If you’ve got a picky dog or cat, you know how frustrating (and sometimes funny) mealtime can be. The good news? With a few simple tricks, you can tempt even the fussiest furball and turn mealtime into something they actually look forward to.

Green tripe can be your best friend! Its smells awful but they love it. Add it to your pets food to entice them to eat.

You can buy it locally or online. We recommend Saving Pets Store Green Tripe (5% off this URL) or  My Pet Carnivore Green Beef Tripe (get 5% off with coupon code: savingpets).

Add some fresh add-ins like a raw or gently cooked egg, bone broth, raw fermented goats milk, sardines, fruits and veggies to try to entice your pet.

Warm your pets food on the stove (do not microwave because it destroys nutrients) to make the food more palatable.

Also, touch and gentle massage around the ears, neck and spine before meals can help relax a stressed picky eater.

Turning Up Noses? Tasty Tricks for Picky Pets…

Getting a picky pup or kitty to eat can feel a bit like negotiating with a tiny, furry food critic — but don’t worry, there are plenty of tricks to win them over. For dogs, sometimes it’s as simple as making their meal smell irresistible. Warming up the food just a little can bring out the aroma, and adding a splash of bone broth or a sprinkle of freeze-dried toppers can really get tails wagging. Some pups like a bit of variety, so mixing in a spoonful of gently cooked meat or rotating flavors can make dinner more exciting. And if your dog tends to turn their nose up, try serving smaller portions more often or sticking to set mealtimes — it can make the food seem like more of a treat.

Cats, on the other hand, are famous for being the divas of the dining world. One day they love something, the next day they act like it never existed. The key is to experiment with texture — some kitties are all about pâté, while others will only eat shreds or crunchy freeze-dried bites. Adding a little warm water, tuna juice, or broth can boost flavor and smell, which often makes it more tempting. Since cats love their food fresh, smaller meals served a few times a day can work better than one big portion. And remember — keep things calm and stress-free at mealtime. A relaxed vibe (and maybe a little cheerleading from you) can help even the pickiest eaters decide their bowl isn’t so bad after all.

Featured Products:

  1. Herbsmith Sassy Cat Kibble Seasoning (10% coupon: SAVINGPETS)
    Varies

    Made with no grain, no fillers, & no artificial preservatives, Sassy Cat Kibble Seasoning help cats live naturally. With 100% USA-sourced ingredients, our treats were developed with the carnivore in mind. Sprinkle it over your kitty’s food and they’ll meow for more!

    Buy Now

    We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

  2. Solutions Pet Products Beef Jiggles (5% off this URL)
    $11.50

    A powerhouse of regenerative nutrition and natural fermentation — these grass-fed beef gelatin treats are more than just a fun topper — they’re packed with benefits to support whole-body wellness

    What makes them special?

    ✔️ Beef gelatin to nourish joints, digestion, and skin

    ✔️ Fermented red beet juice (kvass) — a rich, whole food source of Vitamin C to boost collagen absorption

    ✔️ Regeneratively raised animals — because quality starts at the source

    Fun fact: Pairing collagen with real Vitamin C (like that found in kvass!) helps the body actually use collagen — meaning more support for joints, skin, and gut.


    Buy Now

    We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

  3. Smiling Dog Kibble Seasoning (10% coupon: SAVINGPETS)

    Smiling Dog Kibble Seasonings are made purely of real meat and whole fruits, vegetables, or cheese to help dogs live the way they are supposed to. The ingredients on the label say it all: only meat, vegetables, fruits, or cheeses. A delicious, 100% US-sourced, freeze-dried kibble topper that’s sure to delight even the pickiest of pups! 

    Our Cheese Kibble Seasonings are human-grade, made to season your dog’s food (or your own).

    Buy Now

    We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Additional Information:

perfectly rawsome logo lr

“Picky Eaters?” By Perfectly Rawsome.

Image 9 4 25 at 9.59 PM

“How to Get a Picky Cat to Eat: 6 Tips From A Cat Nutritionist”  by Melina Grin.

two crazy cat ladies logo lr

“Will My Cat Ever Eat Something New?”  By Jae Kennedy.

Recommendations:

  1. Consistency is key. Give them 15 minutes to eat their food. Pick it up if they don’t eat and have them wait until their next meal.
  2. Give them the same food for the next meal.
  3. Dogs will not starve themselves. 
  4. For cats offer smaller meals several times a day. Also, adjust portion sizes for dogs.
  5. If your pet doesn’t like a particular food, mix it with a food they do like. They like variety like we do!
  6. Adjust temperature and the moisture level. 
  7. Add meal toppers.

recommended Products:

Saving Pets Store Logo lr

Get 5% off everything in the Saving Pets Store.

Related Info graphics:

We encourage you to download and share these graphics for personal use and on social media, if desired. However, please note that these graphics cannot be altered in any manner, and you are not authorized to present them as your original creations.

The graphics presented herein are the intellectual property of the identified original creators, used with permission here, or are the result of our own development. Any use for resale or commercial purposes requires explicit written consent from the content creators.

Is your dog or cat a picky eater?
Getting creative with picky pets
Pork for picky pets lr
beef jiggles lr

Related Topics:

Theme image of a jar of coins with a heart growing out of it.

Have we helped?

We’ve poured our hearts into creating this website for you, and we’re still bustling with excitement to keep it going! As a team of volunteers, we’re using our own resources to bring this information to life. There are many ways you can show your support for our efforts. We greatly appreciate it! If we’ve been able to help you on your journey to a healthier pet, we would love it if you consider showing your support.